TrueAchievements Polls Forum

Forum for our TrueAchievement Polls

Is your Commander Shepard morally good or bad?

AuthorMessage
Pellsworth
206,464
Pellsworth - 4 achievements glitched in a day across 2 games. Not cool
206,464 TrueAchievement Points128 posts
Last post: 14 Aug 13 at 02:04
Posted on 05 March 12 at 01:05
N0T PENNYS B0AT said:osubluejacket said:...although I TOTALLY dumped Ashley for Miranda and don't regret it whatsoever.Can't blame you. Besides Trip from Enslaved, Miranda is probably the best looking character in any game.Not gonna lie, I made a beeline for Tali in ME2. As if I don't want to know what happens when a human gets it on with a Quarian...
FinderKeeper
77,994
FinderKeeper - Portugal equalizer in the last 30 seconds = *facepalm*
Registered on 04 May 2009 (Year 2 - beta)TrueAchievements site promoter1,168 posts
Last post: 17 Nov at 05:19
Posted on 05 March 12 at 01:17
osubluejacket said:N0T PENNYS B0AT said:osubluejacket said:...although I TOTALLY dumped Ashley for Miranda and don't regret it whatsoever.Can't blame you. Besides After Trip from Enslaved, Miranda is probably the best looking character in any game.I'd take either in a coin flip... Trip is one smokin' hot ginger, if I do say so myself.Fixed NPB's statement... and you win teh intarwebz for today, obj... toast
Mame Tobikomi! Bean Dive COMPREET-O! Completion from 37.45 to 26.65!
Joker7175
81,548
Joker7175 - TrueTrophies.com FTW
81,548 TrueAchievement Points210 posts
Last post: 05 Nov 13 at 04:01
Posted on 05 March 12 at 01:47
Pellsworth said:N0T PENNYS B0AT said:osubluejacket said:...although I TOTALLY dumped Ashley for Miranda and don't regret it whatsoever.Can't blame you. Besides Trip from Enslaved, Miranda is probably the best looking character in any game.Not gonna lie, I made a beeline for Tali in ME2. As if I don't want to know what happens when a human gets it on with a Quarian...I did as well. I played 1 twice, first time with Liara, then Ashley the second time. Played 2, dumped Ashley for Miranda, and later on after completing the game, dumped Miranda for Tali. Nice that you could do that. My Shepard is a whore, and I like it that way lol
HybridPK
130,276
HybridPK - TOO MANY GAMES
Achievement Completion Percentage: 86.18% (Includes owned DLC) - 38 more achievements required to reach 87%Registered on 07 September 2008 (Year 1 - alpha)213 posts
Last post: 21 May 13 at 07:33
Posted on 05 March 12 at 01:48
My primary Shepard is a Vanguard. Background history says he spent his childhood on Earth as an urchin and enlisted in the military at the age of 18. Prior to the events of Eden Prime, his whole squad was eliminated by a Thresher Maw attack on Akuze. The event changed him and he vowed to never let an event like that happen ever again.

I have played through both games as "mostly paragon." When it comes to the bigger decisions (saving lives, sticking to my end of the bargain, righting wrongs, etc), I have selected the paragon options since they feel more appropriate. When it comes to smaller decisions and certain dialogue options and interrupts, I use the more intimidating options. I can't always be a nice guy.

The only casualty since the events of Akuze was Gunnery Chief Ashley Williams. Finding Corporal Toombs was nice, but the two of them don't seem to see eye-to-eye since Shepard was shoehorned into working for Cerberus.
LegendaryMarvel
120,550 TrueAchievement Points85 posts
Last post: 29 May at 14:08
Posted on 05 March 12 at 02:40
My first play through I went almost strictly Paragon, however, in my more recent play through's I've gone with mostly Renegade. I have become a bit of a cynic (in the games universe) as of late, so it just fits.
Aesop Blood
123,984
Aesop Blood - I miss NPB
123,984 TrueAchievement PointsAchievement Completion Percentage: 64.93% (Includes owned DLC) - 5 more achievements required to reach 65%200 posts
Last post: 14 Feb 13 at 18:54
Posted on 05 March 12 at 02:46
Pellsworth said:N0T PENNYS B0AT said:osubluejacket said:...although I TOTALLY dumped Ashley for Miranda and don't regret it whatsoever.Can't blame you. Besides Trip from Enslaved, Miranda is probably the best looking character in any game.Not gonna lie, I made a beeline for Tali in ME2. As if I don't want to know what happens when a human gets it on with a Quarian...The world may never know........

Also, I play the mostly Paragon route. I mean you can't always be civil and allow those reporters to go without a punch to the face
Dreamers always chase, but never get
Ligerslayer
202,772
Ligerslayer
202,772 TrueAchievement Points24 posts
Last post: 25 Apr 13 at 21:34
Posted on 05 March 12 at 03:28
My Paragon points were always full by the end of the game, but that doesn't mean I didn't have a healthy amount of Renegade points built up as well. I always had the Paragon answer available to me, and the Renegade about 1/2 the time.

HybridPK has it exactly right. You can't always be a nice guy... :)
darthluigi7
131,487
darthluigi7
Achievement Completion Percentage: 75.01% (Includes owned DLC) - 55 more achievements required to reach 76%TrueAchievement Site Rank: 30,546 out of 278,82948 posts
Last post: 14 Nov 13 at 05:55
Posted on 05 March 12 at 03:57, Edited on 05 March 12 at 03:58 by darthluigi7
Honestly I typically go both ways, but there wasn't an option for it in the poll. I have a paragon Shepard and a renegade one, both started in ME1. However there are some points in the game where I do renegade every time just cause, like killing the council haha wink
Code Sumeragii
59,433 TrueAchievement PointsAchievement Completion Percentage: 45.50% (Includes owned DLC) - 25 more achievements required to reach 46%126 posts
Last post: 27 Oct at 05:29
Posted on 05 March 12 at 04:01
I have a hard time playing through any game renegade, so I'm always completely paragon.
Spoooooky
53,267
Spoooooky - Yeah.. I'm not sure if i agree with Ricks decision.
Achievement Completion Percentage: 61.32% (Includes owned DLC) - 19 more achievements required to reach 62%Donated to TrueAchievements.com115 posts
Last post: 01 Apr 13 at 21:59
Posted on 05 March 12 at 04:50, Edited on 05 March 12 at 04:54 by Spoooooky
N0T PENNYS B0AT said:osubluejacket said:...although I TOTALLY dumped Ashley for Miranda and don't regret it whatsoever.Can't blame you. Besides Trip from Enslaved, Miranda is probably the best looking character in any game.I couldn’t agree more, Trip takes my vote every time.

As for me I played the good guy but made a relationship with Jack.
SpectreSubZero - Diablo 3 on Xbox One...hella amazing!
TrueAchievement Ratio: 1.6087Registered on 26 March 2009 (Year 2 - beta)2,204 posts
Last post: 08 Nov at 21:45
Posted on 05 March 12 at 05:03
All paragon
Why so blue Panda Bear?
Ryknowmetalhead - awaken  awareness  preparation
Achievement Completion Percentage: 89.36% (Includes owned DLC) - 28 more achievements required to reach 90%TrueAchievement Ratio: 2.1820199 posts
Last post: 08 Aug at 21:43
Posted on 05 March 12 at 05:05
Completely paragon unless an achievement calls for a certain action.
www.youtube.com/creativementality
Kennyannydenny - Viral Month is awesome! This is the first time i participated and i like it a lot.
TrueAchievements Pro user58 completed games(Includes owned DLC)456 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 23:08
Posted on 05 March 12 at 08:07
Always completely paragon....
Devonian AUS
163,671
Devonian AUS - Ok - this is Devo's last post on TA.com. To all my friends, it's been a pleasure gaming with you over the years...
Achievement Completion Percentage: 95.03% (Includes owned DLC) - 40 more achievements required to reach 96%75 completed games(Includes owned DLC)1,010 posts
Last post: 20 May 13 at 22:20
Posted on 05 March 12 at 08:08
My original Shepard (Dev Shepard) is vastly paragon, with some minor renegade moments when idiots give me the shites, but for the vast majority of the time Dev Shepard is so righteous and morally straight he would make a lesser person vomit.

I have also played through as a complete ass (renegade) which is super fun.

Once ME3 had a release date, I played through both ME & ME2 as a paragon and a renegade to refresh my memory of how things went. Also, now I can see both Dev Shepard (Paragon) & Devo Shepard's (Renegade) conclusions in ME3.

I've got the Friday off work and am about to sink 30+ hours into the game over 3 days. It'll be like I am a student again. lol.
Who Then Now?
Gen Fire Dragon
131,327 TrueAchievement Points122 posts
Last post: 08 Nov at 02:44
Posted on 05 March 12 at 08:12
My Shepard is always a shining example of a pure Paragon, I just have major problems in going evil. I've tried to do Renegade/Dark Side/etc runs in the past in various games and I just have a really hard time doing it, I can make it as far as the end of the prologue before I decide that I can't stand to be that evil and change to a good run.

If there are evil achievements I'll get them, but it'll either be by doing it and then reloading a prior save or by doing a very challenging for me evil run where I end up doing everything good except for the specific things I need to do to get the achievements. Out of the some 10 or so completions of Mass Effect I have, I've yet to do a full Renegade... got the 75% that I needed and then switched.
Pyro1099
117,510
Pyro1099 - HOLY SHIT... My completion percentage went down 11 percent with the MCC.
Achievement Completion Percentage: 86.10% (Includes owned DLC) - 37 more achievements required to reach 87%TrueAchievements Pro user279 posts
Last post: 15 Nov at 20:30
Posted on 05 March 12 at 08:50
Here is to hoping there is a sneaky piece of DLC that requires you to have had the same relationship through the 3 games. Like there was in ME2 for Liara.
[b][u]Computer Nerd, Music Lover, Gaming Addict.[/u][/b] Liked my blog? Follow and comment please.
Wayens
94,103
Wayens - ah, there it is ;p
94,103 TrueAchievement Points312 posts
Last post: 03 May at 07:39
Posted on 05 March 12 at 09:31
I've almost never made a big decision in Mass Effect with a Renegade choice. So I'm counted as a Paragon Shep. Some Renegade interrupts in 2 were fun though. ;>
Pyro1099
117,510
Pyro1099 - HOLY SHIT... My completion percentage went down 11 percent with the MCC.
Achievement Completion Percentage: 86.10% (Includes owned DLC) - 37 more achievements required to reach 87%TrueAchievements Pro user279 posts
Last post: 15 Nov at 20:30
Posted on 05 March 12 at 10:12
Every decision is always Paragon. If I end up doing a Renegade choice I revert to a earlier save.
[b][u]Computer Nerd, Music Lover, Gaming Addict.[/u][/b] Liked my blog? Follow and comment please.
xCRiMZoNx
125,272
xCRiMZoNx - Wow TMCC dropped by completion % by 5% :/
125,272 TrueAchievement Points560 posts
Last post: 25 Nov at 08:18
Posted on 05 March 12 at 10:17
On my “real Shepard” play though I get really involved with the game and try to make my decisions as closely as I can guess I would make them if the situation was real. Overall I do make some Renegade decisions in the heat of the moment, but overall I am “Mostly Paragon.”
steelscream
56,845
steelscream
56,845 TrueAchievement Points2 posts
Last post: 05 Mar 12 at 11:07
Posted on 05 March 12 at 11:07
All renegade, all the time. No good reason for it, I just happened to start that way in ME1 and never stopped. Someday I'll go back to 1 and run a character up through all 3 going paragon, but that will be when I'm just running through to clean up achievements I missed.