Site Wishlist

Got some ideas about how to make the site better? Post them here

Lock down time for Gaming sessions

AuthorMessage
YouAreGod
153,978
YouAreGod - well it appears last nights problems wiped my friends list on xbl. anyone else?
TrueAchievements site super-promoterTA Pro user44 posts
Last post: 03 Oct 12 at 11:05
Posted on 01 July 12 at 22:39
Okay, so how many people either host or join a gaming session, for someone, or multiple people to leave right near the end. if you have then you know how annoying it is. if not then trust me, it can ruin the session completely, if your relying on 8 people to start and 1 leaves, chances are, you won't find someone else or even have a back up.

My idea is a lock down time, which when there is an hour before the session, or possibly even 90 minutes, everyone who has joined the session can no longer leave, this will allow you to give them negative feedback in they don't show up. Which lets others see how reliable the person is.
Without this lock down, people can join and leave 10 minutes before the session and get no negative feedback or anything against them. This would make people think twice about joining a session if they aren't 100% genuine about taking part.
BuffyNixx
135,856
BuffyNixx - just did the update for aliens and it reset all of my stats. i had 2 achievements left..
135,856  TrueAchievements points3 posts
Last post: 01 Jul 12 at 22:49
Posted on 01 July 12 at 22:49
something needs to be done about this -.- joined a full gaming session and the host ended the session 10 minutes before the start time because he recently got the achievements.
& when i've made my own sessions i've had people leave right near the start time which completely ruins the session because we then don't have enough players. i agree with 'youaregod' about a lockdown. it may be a really good improvement to the sessions.
Mystic Typh00n - EA is discontinuing online passes.
TrueAchievements Walkthrough SupervisorTrueAchievements Reported Content Evaluator3,913 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 17:53
Posted on 01 July 12 at 23:23
I'm almost positive that people can't leave the session within an hour of the start of it.

Somebody else correct me if I'm wrong.
How much for the whole kitten kaboodle?
YouAreGod
153,978
YouAreGod - well it appears last nights problems wiped my friends list on xbl. anyone else?
TrueAchievements site super-promoterTA Pro user44 posts
Last post: 03 Oct 12 at 11:05
Posted on 01 July 12 at 23:38
sorry but to my knowledge you are wrong, happened to me today, hosted a halo 3 session, 15 mins from the start time the 8th person left, luckily we could use a guest account.
the way i see it, don't join a session to then quit out a couple hours later because "You can't make it"
it happens nearly everytime for me but i can't do anything about it, in terms of letting other people know etc.
Mystic Typh00n - EA is discontinuing online passes.
TrueAchievements Walkthrough SupervisorTrueAchievements Reported Content Evaluator3,913 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 17:53
Posted on 01 July 12 at 23:48
Ya know what, I was thinking of the host kicking people.

My bad redface

But there's a reason I said "Somebody else correct me" wink
How much for the whole kitten kaboodle?
Spilner
285,268
Spilner - Even though i dont enjoy games much anymore i highly recommend far cry 3
9,172 comments541 solutions9,270 posts
Last post: 22 Jan at 09:39
Posted on 01 July 12 at 23:59
Mystic Typh00n said:I'm almost positive that people can't leave the session within an hour of the start of it.

Somebody else correct me if I'm wrong.
It used to be a thing you're not going mad, i thought it still was in place but ive seen people leave minutes before... and to be perfectly honest the fact its gone is fucking moronic.
Normality has resumed in the crazed mind of a nutjob
Mystic Typh00n - EA is discontinuing online passes.
TrueAchievements Walkthrough SupervisorTrueAchievements Reported Content Evaluator3,913 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 17:53
Posted on 02 July 12 at 00:04
I knew it!

Should never second guess myself :p
How much for the whole kitten kaboodle?
YouAreGod
153,978
YouAreGod - well it appears last nights problems wiped my friends list on xbl. anyone else?
TrueAchievements site super-promoterTA Pro user44 posts
Last post: 03 Oct 12 at 11:05
Posted on 02 July 12 at 00:07
well that makes sense, but why exactly would they of got rid of the feature? o.O sounds ridiculous to me.
would be an awesome feature to get back again
alklein92201
182,114
alklein92201
Achievement Completion Percentage: 46.78% (Includes owned DLC) - 32 more achievements required to reach 47%TrueAchievements Game Info Editor6,663 posts
Last post: 16 May at 17:24
Posted on 02 July 12 at 00:08
I've never been able to leave a session with less than 30 minutes until start time, and can confirm it was still not letting me as of a few days ago. If I'm simply mistaken, then this definitely needs to be implemented. If I can't remove a user with less than an hour, when I am knowingly having one less person in the session, why can they just leave at the last minute possibly ruining the entire session for everyone?
YouAreGod
153,978
YouAreGod - well it appears last nights problems wiped my friends list on xbl. anyone else?
TrueAchievements site super-promoterTA Pro user44 posts
Last post: 03 Oct 12 at 11:05
Posted on 02 July 12 at 00:16
weird :S all i know is that the person who was in my session today left with session 17 mins before the start time.
i think it would be helpful for everyone if they were able to be given neg feedback, so when people are looking through their feedback they can take into account the chance they may not show and go from there, whether they remove them and let someone else take the spot or just take their chances.
Spilner
285,268
Spilner - Even though i dont enjoy games much anymore i highly recommend far cry 3
9,172 comments541 solutions9,270 posts
Last post: 22 Jan at 09:39
Posted on 02 July 12 at 00:28
Im wiht alklein, i dont know how to leave early. I had thought the obvious exploits had been removed but perhaps im wrong/
Normality has resumed in the crazed mind of a nutjob
YouAreGod
153,978
YouAreGod - well it appears last nights problems wiped my friends list on xbl. anyone else?
TrueAchievements site super-promoterTA Pro user44 posts
Last post: 03 Oct 12 at 11:05
Posted on 02 July 12 at 00:33
from what i've seen previously, its the standard way you leave a session, below is the session i did earlier, if you look, he left at 17:43 but got the same for him as i did for the person previously.
Boosting Gaming Session for Halo 3
Spilner
285,268
Spilner - Even though i dont enjoy games much anymore i highly recommend far cry 3
9,172 comments541 solutions9,270 posts
Last post: 22 Jan at 09:39
Posted on 02 July 12 at 00:45
I thought the rules were 2 hours before a session to kick people and an hour before a session for someone to leave.
Normality has resumed in the crazed mind of a nutjob
YouAreGod
153,978
YouAreGod - well it appears last nights problems wiped my friends list on xbl. anyone else?
TrueAchievements site super-promoterTA Pro user44 posts
Last post: 03 Oct 12 at 11:05
Posted on 02 July 12 at 12:25
I'm not sure, I've never needed to kick or leave.close to the end, I'm just going by my experiences of people leaving my sessions tbh
RedDeadKBII
100,830
RedDeadKBII
Achievement Completion Percentage: 98.32% (Includes owned DLC) - 19 more achievements required to reach 99%53 completed games(Includes owned DLC)1,017 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 21:56
Posted on 02 July 12 at 13:31
I don't know how helpful this will be, when I create sessions I usually just let anyone in without looking at their feedback. Maybe I should start looking at it, but I guess I've been lucky that my sessions usually go without a hitch.
YouAreGod
153,978
YouAreGod - well it appears last nights problems wiped my friends list on xbl. anyone else?
TrueAchievements site super-promoterTA Pro user44 posts
Last post: 03 Oct 12 at 11:05
Posted on 02 July 12 at 13:56
thats one of the points im trying to make, if you look at their feedback, you won't know if they're likely to leave anyway because we can't make it known, unless they stay in the session and do a no show, i think there should be some way of giving a type of feedback for leaving in short notice to warn others in the feedback
SpectreSubZero - If 5000 people repost this status, Dog of Thunder will join Toddy's completion challenge.
Achievement Completion Percentage: 67.06% (Includes owned DLC) - 47 more achievements required to reach 68%TrueAchievement Ratio: 1.57132,127 posts
Last post: 17 May at 09:40
Posted on 02 July 12 at 16:56
I think a lock-in time is a great idea
Why so blue Panda Bear?
o DEEVIUS o
210,572
o DEEVIUS o - So I gets a new PC - What can I play with WIN 8?
TrueAchievement Ratio: 1.8465TA Pro user1,078 posts
Last post: 17 May at 17:58
Posted on 04 July 12 at 22:51, Edited on 04 July 12 at 22:55 by o DEEVIUS o
Mystic Typh00n said:I'm almost positive that people can't leave the session within an hour of the start of it.

Somebody else correct me if I'm wrong.
I've had members of my sessions (recently) pulling out as close as 30 mins before a session start. angry This allows no time to find a replacement.

A lockdown time assigned by the host at the session's creation of either 1, 2, 3 or 6 hours depending on the nature of the session is a very good idea.

Then if any TA members think they may not make the session, instead of destroying the session by withdrawing late to avoid negative feedback, they simply wont join.

The only people to dislike this idea would be those who f*ck sessions up and know they wont receive any feedback. I give full support to this, thumbs up smile
Join the True Completion Percentage Leaderboard if you've started at least 100 games
Cragz1337
20,341
Cragz1337
20,341  TrueAchievements pointsTrueAchievement Ratio: 1.24914 posts
Last post: 04 Jul 12 at 23:03
Posted on 04 July 12 at 23:03
@ o Deevius o
yeah man I remember you bringing this idea up aloong time ago but nothing eevr come out of it. but loads a peaople agreed it was gud. We need to make the admin aware of it this time, if anythings gonna be done, maybe start a leaderboard to act as like a signature board for all those who support, now that other guys are bringing it up againe
True Completionist
Fluzi Goliath
58,467  TrueAchievements pointsAchievement Completion Percentage: 31.19% (Includes owned DLC) - 63 more achievements required to reach 32%5 posts
Last post: 04 Jul 12 at 23:07
Posted on 04 July 12 at 23:07
i wuz behind Deev when he did that
I'd join that leaderboard :o)
Rememba rememba the 11th of Septemba