RPG Addicts!

Board for the "RPG Addicts!" leaderboards

Favorite RPG of all time?

AuthorMessage
Pocrage
232,104
Pocrage - Back to the RPG Grind
Achievement Completion Percentage: 74.14% (Includes owned DLC) - 76 more achievements required to reach 75%145 completed games(Includes owned DLC)170 posts
Last post: 06 May at 22:22
Posted on 13 September 08 at 20:09, Edited on 13 September 08 at 20:09 by Pocrage
Hey all, I was just wondering what is your favorite RPG of all time?

Mine has to be one of the first ones I played, Chrono Trigger. I think that this is the only game that I replayed in its entirety like 20+ times over the years, on the SNES, on the PS1, and on an emulator (i got the original cartridge so no biggie). And when it comes out again on the DS, I'm gonna rack up some more playthroughs.

toast

So, whats yours?
NightStalkar
223,301
NightStalkar
Registered on 29 August 2008 (Year 1 - alpha)TA Pro user2,455 posts
Last post: 20 Apr 11 at 07:37
Posted on 14 September 08 at 01:06
All time is such a rouch answer since you're comparing to such a wide-array of games. I'm stuck between elder scrolls III: morrowind and shenmue.

I'm gonna have to say morrowind though. :)
Crimson Drifter - The rippin' and the tearin'
Achievement Completion Percentage: 88.50% (Includes owned DLC) - 36 more achievements required to reach 89%Site Helper2,787 posts
Last post: 18 May at 22:58
Posted on 14 September 08 at 02:57
ah one of the most difficult answers of all time. I've played so many throughout my years of gaming. I would have to say...

Star Ocean for PS1 or Final Fantasy Tactics
Arkzein
114,890
Arkzein
Registered on 21 August 2008 (Year 1 - alpha)Achievement Completion Percentage: 98.68% (Includes owned DLC) - 9 more achievements required to reach 99%478 posts
Last post: 02 Mar at 11:25
Posted on 16 September 08 at 09:35, Edited on 16 September 08 at 09:36 by Arkzein
I'd have to go for Baldurs Gate, ever so closely followed by Super Metroid. Two of the games in my top 5, of any genre.
Blackflame0729 - Play? Sleep?   Sleep < Play
Achievement Completion Percentage: 75.15% (Includes owned DLC) - 26 more achievements required to reach 76%14 completed games(Includes owned DLC)233 posts
Last post: 22 Oct 11 at 21:43
Posted on 16 September 08 at 19:54
All of the Zelda games are very good.
knight0fkh0nshu - Is it possible that EA is turning over a new leaf?
18 reviewsAchievement Completion Percentage: 68.54% (Includes owned DLC) - 73 more achievements required to reach 69%518 posts
Last post: 15 May at 00:03
Posted on 02 November 08 at 22:04
I'm going to say the Baldur's Gate/Icewind Dale series
Jackso O Gilead - Know your role and Shut your.... damn mouth
122,847  TrueAchievements points36 completed games(Includes owned DLC)68 posts
Last post: 17 May at 23:40
Posted on 22 November 08 at 12:19
Its a close 3 way tie, between Final Fantasy 6(used to play the co-op back in 3rd grade), Suikoden II(PS1)(if you haven't played it try and find it) and Star Ocean 2(the most customization I've seen in an rpg)
Cougar24
121,318
Cougar24
121,318  TrueAchievements pointsDonated to TrueAchievements.com30 posts
Last post: 01 Jul 11 at 15:30
Posted on 24 December 08 at 03:34
I've gotta agree with NightStalker. I would say a 3-way tie between Morrowind, Shenmue, and Xenogears.
albajos
354,158
albajos - "My eyes are up here, Ash" - Sam
354,158  TrueAchievements pointsTrueAchievement Site Rank: 1,077 out of 206,2833,747 posts
Last post: 09 May at 12:27
Posted on 30 December 08 at 23:34
Probably Final Fantasy IX, but I'm actually playing Final Fantasy VI for the first time right now, and it does have many elements that makes it a classic.
I'll give my final verdict when the world ends.
Crimson Drifter - The rippin' and the tearin'
Achievement Completion Percentage: 88.50% (Includes owned DLC) - 36 more achievements required to reach 89%Site Helper2,787 posts
Last post: 18 May at 22:58
Posted on 02 January 09 at 01:17
gah I forgot about Xenogears. damn I want to play that now lol. Loved the battle system as the human characters.
albajos
354,158
albajos - "My eyes are up here, Ash" - Sam
354,158  TrueAchievements pointsTrueAchievement Site Rank: 1,077 out of 206,2833,747 posts
Last post: 09 May at 12:27
Posted on 03 January 09 at 04:49
But there are two others I like to mention.

Chrono Trigger I've never played, but is of many hailed as the greatest RPG of all time.
But I just recently also got Super Mario RPG of the Wii Console Vault, which is of many others the greatest ever.

At least I can say that Squaresoft really had a good thing going. After they joined up with Enix and entered the 21st Century they gone more action-based, which personally I don't like. But on the other hand they also released Dragon Quest: The Curse of the King which was a major leap towards divineness.
All work and no play makes Jos a dull boy.
Clever Jake
159,326
Clever Jake - Everyone wants the hammer!
TrueAchievements AdministratorRegistered on 10 July 2008 (Year 1 - alpha)6,393 posts
Last post: Today at 13:53
Posted on 03 January 09 at 16:13
knight0fkh0nshu said:I'm going to say the Baldur's Gate/Icewind Dale seriesI loved those games!
"The path of my life is strewn with cowpats from the devil's own satanic herd."
Crimson Drifter - The rippin' and the tearin'
Achievement Completion Percentage: 88.50% (Includes owned DLC) - 36 more achievements required to reach 89%Site Helper2,787 posts
Last post: 18 May at 22:58
Posted on 03 January 09 at 20:04
Clever Jake said:knight0fkh0nshu said:I'm going to say the Baldur's Gate/Icewind Dale seriesI loved those games!I tried Baldurs Gate way back when, but I just couldn't get the hang of it as I always got my ass handed to me in tiny bits over and over again. ungh maybe I'll pick it up one day and try it on my laptop
Strikingstriker - OOOOH YEAAAA
82,859  TrueAchievements points161 posts
Last post: 31 May 09 at 01:04
Posted on 04 January 09 at 04:49
I would say fable II because the fantacy world really shined and the achieviement list was the most fun 1000 ever!!!
prime261
60,198
prime261
60,198  TrueAchievements pointsAchievement Completion Percentage: 51.31% (Includes owned DLC) - 33 more achievements required to reach 52%596 posts
Last post: 23 Apr 10 at 21:15
Posted on 04 January 09 at 17:23
for me its easily the legend of dragoon such a great story and game play is so different from most other rpgs
ChakramPrincess - Currently addicted to Pokemon, shiny hunting. Can't wait for X & Y for the 3DS
135,279  TrueAchievements points19 posts
Last post: 03 Jun 11 at 06:08
Posted on 05 January 09 at 07:42, Edited on 05 January 09 at 07:43 by ChakramPrincess
I have too many favourites. Oblivion, World of Warcraft, Guild Wars, Lost Odyssey, Secret of Mana, Neverwinter Nights (have sunk hundreds of hours into that over the years), Diablo II, The Last Remnant, The World Ends With You, Mass Effect, Final Fantasy XII and Pokemon Diamond. Many more as well.
knight0fkh0nshu - Is it possible that EA is turning over a new leaf?
18 reviewsAchievement Completion Percentage: 68.54% (Includes owned DLC) - 73 more achievements required to reach 69%518 posts
Last post: 15 May at 00:03
Posted on 10 February 09 at 22:26
Crimson Drifter said:Clever Jake said:knight0fkh0nshu said:I'm going to say the Baldur's Gate/Icewind Dale seriesI loved those games!I tried Baldurs Gate way back when, but I just couldn't get the hang of it as I always got my ass handed to me in tiny bits over and over again. ungh maybe I'll pick it up one day and try it on my laptopThey are classics. If you had trouble with BG, try Icewind Dale first...you get to create all 6 characters at the start instead of just creating one for the whole game in Baldur's Gate.
Crimson Drifter - The rippin' and the tearin'
Achievement Completion Percentage: 88.50% (Includes owned DLC) - 36 more achievements required to reach 89%Site Helper2,787 posts
Last post: 18 May at 22:58
Posted on 28 February 09 at 06:58
Anyone ever play Vandal Hearts? That was the first grid based RPG I ever played and I loved it!
~TA Clan~ You can cut the tension with a +6 Sword!
BoneAtom
20,840
BoneAtom
20,840  TrueAchievements points2 posts
Last post: 28 Feb 09 at 13:06
Posted on 28 February 09 at 13:06
Hard choice

Final fantasy X is the only rpg i replayed 20 times have to love the blitz ball lol
Althax
70,116
Althax
70,116  TrueAchievements pointsAchievement Completion Percentage: 52.58% (Includes owned DLC) - 22 more achievements required to reach 53%20 posts
Last post: 13 Dec 10 at 22:24
Posted on 04 March 09 at 18:55
The best RPG in terms of story I ever played was definetly Planescape: Torment, there were several moments in that game where I got chills from reading the dialogue.

Chrono Trigger is an old favorite but I doubt it would hold up to time for me now. I loved Final Fantasy 3 with the espers and all that, I replayed that several times over and over.

I couldn't pick a favorite though, there's too many that I've enjoyed over the years. I'm bummed now that there just isn't enough time to play the RPG's as much as I would like. I'm just too busy with family and life and work and I tend to get lost in the big ones unless I play pretty consistently, which is difficult.