TA Top Five: Morally Dubious Achievements

The Overlord II one looks horrible, could never do that!

All the others though, I did not even feel bad, they aren't real, achievements are!

Quite a good obscure top 5 this week :D

Agreed. Also kind of feel like the achievement for dealing with the bomb in Megaton (Fallout 3) would be good, if you chose to detonate it. Just watching that explosion from Tenpenny Tower... aahhh, those evil karma days...

Great list. I have a few of these.

i have 4 out of the top 5 ohh i'm so bad ;)

I suspected Lollipop Chainsaw and RDR would make the top 5 for this topic. Great list this week.

Awesome list. I was just looking through my games and achievements and can't think/find any that weren't already mentioned!

Nice list. I don't have any of those games but the achievements make want to get them LOL

I have all but the fable 2 and overload 2 achievement, Great list!

If only Steam achievements were applicable. There's an achievement in Ys 1 where you have to "Measure a goddess in the creepiest way possible". Let's just say you end up forcing said goddess into a corner, whilst you were escorting her out of a dungeon, and then you put on the Mask of Eyes which turns you invisible. And then *insert questionable content*. There's also a similar achievement in Ys 2 for doing almost the same exact thing to a young male child

Earning all Gold Trophies on Hydro Thunder Hurricane?

That's just pure outrageous, crazy and insane!

I suspected Harvesting All Little Sisters on BioShock being on this list.

I didn't feel evil doing the RDR one; it was one of those women who trick you into getting killed, although I survived and tricked her into letting me hogtie her and put her on some train tracks. Needless to say, it cost her her life.

Kill all the Buffalo made me feel like a bad panda in RDR.

Dastardly is certainly the worst. It doesn't unlock unless you are looking at the girl when she gets hit by the train. Alas, I had to do it twice. :)

6 out of 8.
Missing Overlord II and Lollipop Chainsaw ... and still wish I'd have never started DNF.

HaloMonkey3009 said:Haha, that is what I did. I dragged her for a bit first though.

When I saw the list, RDR was what I thought off.

I am not familiar with the other games but I thought of:

I felt really bad doing Dastardly I really didn't want to do it!

I thought of Skyrim, and what you have to do to get all the Daedric Artifacts......killing friends, family, kids......whatever. To get all of the artifacts.

Most of Saints Row the Thirds list can find a place here... I'm thinking shipping crates in particular made me feel quite wrong...