| Author | Message |
|---|
Last post: 14 Apr at 02:36
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:01 |
| yes eli is |
Last post: 19 Dec 12 at 15:36
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:02, Edited on 06 August 12 at 17:03 by Zacry072 |
| I think a lot of that is mostly right for the QBs. I'd put Stafford above Rivers and Manning above Big Ben. Eli can stay there at #4, I guess. Not a huge fan of him but it's hard to argue against two Super Bowl dubs. I'd switch around quite a few of the RBs. |
Last post: 05 Nov 12 at 07:21
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:06 |
| Glad to see they gave Rodgers a 99! |
Last post: 03 Sep 12 at 18:21
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:07 |
| The fact that Matt Stafford is on the list, and Jay Culter is not is rediculous. Who was Cutler throwing to? Johnny Knox and Devin Hester? Get real. With Marshall, Jeffrey and a healthy Earl Bennett, he will have a great season. Matt Forte is also way too high, maybe he should be at 10... maybe... He's not even in Steven Jackson's zip code. Only reason he had a good statistical season was because the bears offense was him, and thats it. |
Last post: 22 May at 12:42
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:14 |
| DeanoMac21 said:Who was Cutler throwing to?Usually the other team. |
Last post: Yesterday at 17:25
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:27 |
| Tony Romo?? Hahahaha, that's funny, Romo has done nothing worth being rated that high. What about Matt Ryan or Cam Newton. And Ray Rice should be higher in the RB's in my opinion. |
Last post: Yesterday at 19:02
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:31 |
N0T PENNYS B0AT said:DeanoMac21 said:Who was Cutler throwing to?Usually the other team.
Also, I'm quite surprised MJD is #1 for RBs. |
How much for the whole kitten kaboodle? |
Last post: Yesterday at 00:41
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:39 |
| Eli totally doesn't deserve that rating. Romo, however, does. Go Cowboys! |
PWH ~ Hail Purdue! |
Last post: 16 May at 17:16
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:49 |
I hate how Roethlisberger is always considered one of the best QB's in the league. The only thing he's good at is clock management and isn't that easy to tackle, other than that everything is average on him. And don't give me this BS about his super bowl wins, everyone and their mother knows it was their defense that kicked ass, not their QB.
Eli's rating may be a point or two high but I agree with it. Just as long as either of these lists didn't include Cam Newton or Tim Tebow, I suppose I won't be making a huge fuss over any thing else now. |
The Gutless Wonder
"Try not to understand anything I'm saying and it'll all make sense" |
Last post: Yesterday at 17:31
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:50 |
| never understood why people argue about who has the higher rating.if you dont like it just change it when you get a copy of the game lol |
H.I.V---{FLTG}---{RiverDale}---C.PECK---{RiverDale}---{FLTG}---H.I.V |
Last post: 16 May at 17:16
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:57 |
DeanoMac21 said:The fact that Matt Stafford is on the list, and Jay Culter is not is rediculous. Who was Cutler throwing to? Johnny Knox and Devin Hester? Get real. With Marshall, Jeffrey and a healthy Earl Bennett, he will have a great season. Matt Forte is also way too high, maybe he should be at 10... maybe... He's not even in Steven Jackson's zip code. Only reason he had a good statistical season was because the bears offense was him, and thats it.Forte is where he should be, Jackson is hurt almost every year and usually only has 3 or 4 break out games per year. Forte is much more versatile than Jackson with catching the ball out of the backfield. While Forte may not have his strength, his elusiveness and unmentioned acceleration and speed make up for it. And your reason why Forte had a good year because he was the only guy making good numbers on the offense. ??? Think about it... if only one guy on your team is doing anything mentionable, then why wouldn't he be ahead of a lot of other guys in the league?
The Bears are my team and I don't have a problem with Cutler not being on this list because, quite honestly, he hasn't had a great year since he's been in Chicago. I hate the Lions but you have to understand that Stafford threw for over 5,000 yards last season, ended up with like the 5th most yards in a season for any QB and had big help from the cover athlete this year, Calvin Johnson. |
The Gutless Wonder
"Try not to understand anything I'm saying and it'll all make sense" |
Last post: 26 Apr at 03:46
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 17:57 |
| Romo is vastly overrated and the pursuit system in the videos still looks terrible, the defenders take terrible angles and their run animations look so choppy and unnatural... |
Last post: Today at 04:08
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 18:10 |
| Eli has already proven twice he is an ELITE QB!!!! |
Last post: 04 Feb at 18:12
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 18:12 |
| eli has beat brady twice in the superbowl and decimated aaron rodgers yet he is only 4th what a load of bollocks. how many more times does he have to prove himself |
monotom |
Last post: Yesterday at 18:52
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 18:57 |
| lol at MJD as the highest RB, i bet they had to do that or the Jaguars Overall Rating would be under 50! |
Last post: 19 May at 14:50
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 19:06 |
| RODGERS!!!!! |
Last post: 25 Mar at 19:30
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 19:10 |
Eli's numbers are where they should be. I'm sorry, last I checked he has 2 superbowls. He also CARRIED the Giants to another Super Bowl win. Last season alone the defense was ranked in the 20's and rushing was dead last. Just because you hate him, doesn't mean he should be lowered.
For the Romo fanboy... really? How many playoff wins does Romo have? Eli has 2 more Super Bowl wins then Romo has playoff wins. That alone is case closed. |
Last post: 02 Apr at 16:46
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 19:30 |
| I smell the Cowboy/Giants hatred in here HAHA.... Go Broncos!! |
Last post: 21 Mar at 20:15
|
Posted on 06 August 12 at 19:37, Edited on 06 August 12 at 19:41 by CDonns |
Tebow not in top ten.   No Lynch in the top ten and ray rice should be 3 and foster 2. |
Nuffzx, your new litterbox is here. |