The Testament of Sherlock Holmes Review

By Rebecca Smith, 4 years ago
The Sherlock Holmes adventure franchise has been running since 2002, but most gamers didn't know of its existence until 2009's Sherlock Holmes vs Jack the Ripper arrived on the Xbox 360. With PC being the main platform for the series of point-and-clicks, Ripper was a port that carried a few bugs and issues as a result. However, this time Frogwares' sixth instalment in the franchise, The Testament of Sherlock Holmes, has been developed for the console audience. Our official review is here to explain whether this makes any difference and whether this game is worthy of your time.

29/9/12 Logo

Three young children investigate the attic of their home where they find lots of interesting paraphernalia. The item that interests them the most is a Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson puppet show. While trying to pull down Watson's puppet, the strings get broken and it tumbles to the floor. Lodged in the back of the puppet is a book. When the eldest child begins to read, it becomes apparent that this is a lost account of one of the duo's many adventures. Players are then transported back to 1898, where they join Holmes and Watson in the investigation of the theft of a priceless pearl necklace.

Controlling a perfectionist

This first, short case represents the game's tutorial where players are introduced to the control system and the basics of investigation. Although the majority of the controls remain the same as Ripper, the action option is now confined to the A button. RT has been repurposed for a more natural toggle between sprint and the characters' more leisurely pace, with players holding down the trigger for sprinting. That leisurely pace seems quicker than before, making character navigation seem less laborious. Players can still switch between first- and third-person views with the X button, while the notebook, inventory, map and deduction boards remain on the Y button. RB and LB retain their purpose of easy selection of inventory items while on location, or navigating between tabs while in the notebook menu.

Screenshot May 4th 2

Searching for clues is still very much a large part of the game. Clues that need to be observed are marked with a blue magnifying glass, which turns green once all of the information has been collected. Objects with which players can interact are marked with a blue hand; this disappears once those actions are complete. Players that need help can press LT to bring up any clues that have been missed, although this 'sixth sense' now needs a small amount of time to recharge so that the feature can't be abused. Coupled with the game's refusal to move on until all clues have been collected, it is extremely difficult to miss anything in the game.

The harrowing journey

The duo's search for clues takes them on a dark journey where we see sides to Holmes that you never thought existed. Holmes is being accused of forgery, theft and all manner of things, and Watson's faith in his friend is tested to the limit as Holmes' behaviour seemingly deteriorates throughout the game. The pair's decision to not always act on the right side of the law only adds to the intrigue. Their investigation takes them from the rich decor of a judge's abode, through middle-class streets and on to the grimy hovels of Whitechapel. Fans of Ripper will recognise some of the locations and characters, but the only recycled location is the Whitechapel dispensary -- the vast majority of the locations are new.

28/06/2012 - Screen 4

The map plays very little part in the game, as each section of the investigation plays out independently and covers one location at a time. There is little need for players to navigate back to previous locations, with the exception of 221b Baker Street and another location that I won't mention to reduce spoilers. Listening to the dialogue between Holmes and Watson is also imperative, as the pair often state what would be the best step in continuing the investigation. Players always feel guided rather than needing to second-guess where they should be. To some players this may feel like hand-holding, but I feel that it strengthens the game's ability to tell the story with as little confusion as possible.

A puzzling conundrum

Puzzles play a large part in the game too and they range from challenging to fairly easy. Most have instructions for players on what they must do, but not all. There seems to be no method behind those that receive instructions though. Often, the simplest and most obvious puzzles have a full set of instructions, while others leave players guessing what they need to do. Compared to the guidance offered throughout the rest of the game, this seems out of place. Players who find the puzzles too challenging can elect to skip the puzzles, but be aware that skipping a single puzzle will also skip an achievement.

20/07/12 - Screen 2

As mentioned at the beginning of the review, deduction boards also make their welcome return. Whereas the first Sherlock games made players feel like they were there to play the part of Watson who is forever struggling to catch up, the deduction board in Ripper finally brought players onto the same level of realisation as Holmes. You feel like the person leading the investigation and the boards mean that all of the deductions are your own.

London's sights...

One of the greatest improvements in the game lies in the graphics. There is a marked improvement between this game and Ripper. The characters are much more detailed with their expressions often telling the character's feelings before any dialogue is spoken. Unfortunately the same can't be said about lip-syncing, with very little dialogue matched to the characters’ mouth movements.

Screenshot 6

The London environments also show more detail, although these are not perfect either. Players will spend most of their time looking at objects on the ground or at eye-level, but the occasional glances into the sky can show distinct texture box outlines around trees. The instances of pop-up have been drastically reduced, but still happen every now and again.

...and sounds

Watson is seemingly voiced by the same actor responsible for the character in Ripper, although Holmes is now voiced by a different actor. The voice acting is of a very high standard and the range of English accents is very convincing. Even the NPCs have been brought to life admirably, with the exception of the three children that we meet at the start of the game; these often sound like they are simply reading from a script as opposed to acting a part.

Screenshot May 4th 5

Whether this is a drop in the acting standards as opposed to the rest of the cast or just a lack of understanding of the language is not certain, but the entire cast appears to be from Frogwares' native France. Every now and again it tells that English is not the actors' mother tongue, with a couple of different pronunciations of the same word from the same character. The subtitles make the language challenge more obvious. There are a few mis-spellings in the normal dialogue, and some of the children’s' noises made during play or reactions from older characters are just completely different to what appears in the subtitles. This is only a minor detraction from an otherwise stellar performance though.

Achieving full marks

Ripper had a reputation for being an easy 1000G, and this game is not going to do anything to stop that reputation spreading across the franchise. Although there are a couple of missables, the vast majority of the achievements are unlocked through natural story progression. The full 1000G is easily done in one playthrough. That playthrough would take about 10-12 hours if not using a guide. Of course, using a guide would shorten the length of time needed for the full gamerscore, but would also drastically reduce any enjoyment got out of this game.

Screenshot 2


The Testament of Sherlock has one of the darkest and most gripping storylines that I've experienced in the Sherlock Holmes franchise. Players get to see a side of Sherlock Holmes that has never been seen before, and watch as his faithful assistant Watson starts doubting the integrity of his friend. Through the many districts of London, evidence needs to be collected, puzzles have to be solved and deductions need to be made. The journey will take 10-12 hours and rarely feels frustrating.

The controls feel natural and do not feel at all clunky, a rarity for a point-and-click on the Xbox 360. The game looks visually stunning in most places, although occasional texture issues pop up. The voice acting is also pretty good, but players have to bear in mind that English is not the native language of the development team. This only tends to become obvious when viewing the subtitles though. Testament is definitely a game worthy of a purchase for point-and-click fans.
Rebecca Smith
Written by Rebecca Smith
Rebecca is the Newshound Manager at TrueGaming Network. She has been contributing articles since 2010, especially those that involve intimidatingly long lists. When not writing news, she works in an independent game shop so that she can spend all day talking about games too. She'll occasionally go outside.
Thread Posts on this article have been added to a thread in the Gaming News Forum.
Papa El Loro
Papa El Loro
309,832 TrueAchievement Points1,277 posts
Last post: 27 Jan at 18:51
Posted on 29 September 12 at 22:32
Looks so much better then the other game. Great review guys, I'll be playing it.
When Gotham is ashes, you have my permission to die.
278 posts
Last post: 22 May 14 at 06:49
Posted on 29 September 12 at 22:39
I might have to pick this up, I keep seeing ripper and was intrigued but was always distracted by something else. Good to know I waited
34 completed games(Includes owned DLC)Achievement Completion Percentage: 73.13% (Includes owned DLC) - 56 more achievements required to reach 74%22 posts
Last post: 12 May 14 at 22:59
Posted on 29 September 12 at 22:44
I liked the first one for being something different and having a good story. Looks like I'll pick this one up once it drops in price as well.
TrueAchievements NewshoundTrueAchievements Game Info Editor10,160 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 22:17
Posted on 29 September 12 at 22:49
Great review Punky.
Can't wait to pick this up. Really liked the potential in the last one and this one looks like an improvement in every way.
@ChewieOnIce | NewsHound | 'Please don't kill us.' 'Please don't make it so appealing'
Darth Sean85
Darth Sean85
125,972 TrueAchievement Points60 completed games(Includes owned DLC)362 posts
Last post: 29 Sep 13 at 13:26
Posted on 29 September 12 at 23:03
Will be picking this up for sure. Going to wait on a price drop though.
More G's for me, more G's for you, i'll get some G's you'll get some too!!
Achievement Completion Percentage: 94.65% (Includes owned DLC) - 50 more achievements required to reach 95%TrueAchievement Site Rank: 1,628 out of 312,1823,182 posts
Last post: 31 Oct 15 at 01:32
Posted on 29 September 12 at 23:36
Anxious to try this out!
Sgt Malarkey Br
TrueAchievement Ratio: 2.0711Achievement Completion Percentage: 96.92% (Includes owned DLC) - 7 more achievements required to reach 97%4,026 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 03:21
Posted on 29 September 12 at 23:45
Great review, thanks guys
258,912 TrueAchievement PointsAchievement Completion Percentage: 95.26% (Includes owned DLC) - 46 more achievements required to reach 96%240 posts
Last post: 22 Jun at 20:42
Posted on 29 September 12 at 23:54
IDK from the vids I've seen, looks boring. Even though the two are not related, the newer movies have so much action but these games seem to have such a slow pace.
A trying completionist
296,196 TrueAchievement Points770 posts
Last post: 22 Jun at 21:18
Posted on 30 September 12 at 00:08
Will wait for price slash and buy.
MH The Rockstar
Donated to TrueAchievements.com2,806 posts
Last post: 14 May 15 at 17:58
Posted on 30 September 12 at 00:41
Thanks for the review. I was going to pick this up solely based on how much I enjoyed the first - glad to see they haven't taken a step backwards.
Ha ha, Charade you are!
398,110 TrueAchievement Points13,421 comments9,989 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 17:19
Posted on 30 September 12 at 01:23
Looks like a nice change of pace.
219,252 TrueAchievement PointsDonated to TrueAchievements.com946 posts
Last post: 24 Jun at 20:04
Posted on 30 September 12 at 02:08
Thanks for the review! I am definitely going to be playing this at some point!
You are the Detectives; go... and detect.
Dog of Thunder
TrueAchievements Community Events Organizer4,497 posts
Last post: 07 Oct 13 at 17:06
Posted on 30 September 12 at 02:52
The first was something I grabbed for the easy points, but it somehow sucked me into the story. It was a much, much better experience then I was expecting going in and I'm glad to see the next one in the franchise is just as well-crafted.
"Someday you're going to pay for a nice little vacation bungalow for some shrink DoT..." - Van Uden
CyberellaD Nile
156,879 TrueAchievement Points422 posts
Last post: 05 Feb 15 at 19:37
Posted on 30 September 12 at 03:44
Loved the first rendition on the 360 and the story was even stomach turning and kept me guessing the whole game. The first one had a great budget value. Has this one the same or is it a full blown retail?
469,008 TrueAchievement Points129 posts
Last post: 28 Sep 14 at 14:31
Posted on 30 September 12 at 05:03
Haven't got a chance to play this yet due to work, but I am looking forward to it. I have such a passion for point & click games, I cannot wait!
195,271 TrueAchievement Points1,365 posts
Last post: 24 Jun at 22:54
Posted on 30 September 12 at 06:54
CyberellaD Nile said:Loved the first rendition on the 360 and the story was even stomach turning and kept me guessing the whole game. The first one had a great budget value. Has this one the same or is it a full blown retail?Full blown retail
I'm Awkward With Potential: Boss Major
Major Rawne
Major Rawne
70,245 TrueAchievement Points27 completed games(Includes owned DLC)15 posts
Last post: 09 Feb at 22:25
Posted on 30 September 12 at 09:18
Look pretty decent..Think I'm gonna go for this

Removed Gamer
Gamer has been removed
Posted on 30 September 12 at 10:52
i have often thought about getting this
Hooded Claw 006
139,731 TrueAchievement Points574 posts
Last post: 22 Mar 15 at 21:00
Posted on 30 September 12 at 10:54
Bar6arian said:IDK from the vids I've seen, looks boring. Even though the two are not related, the newer movies have so much action but these games seem to have such a slow pace.That's because the movies are nothing like the real Sherlock Holmes. The words Sherlock Holmes and action movie should never be put in the same sentence,.

Anyway, back to the game. Having played all of the Frogwares Holmes games since 2002, I will definitely be picking this up in time. Current price is too high though, will wait for it in a sale or something.
Want to join in the discussion? Please log in or Register For Free to comment.