TA Top Five: Characters You Couldn't Save

TA Top Five: Characters You Couldn't Save

Every time we say goodbye ...

Written by Andrew Ogley (Nexus Grunt) on 29 September 13 at 13:33

Spoiler Warning
The title of this week’s Top Five should give a clear hint that all of the characters featured have met some sort of fate that the player was unable to prevent. In describing the circumstances, and the ultimate fate, it will be necessary to give away some of the details of each of the storylines. We will be revisiting Halo: Reach, Crysis 2, Metro 2033, Metro: Last Light, Batman: Arkham City, Mafia II, Portal 2, and Call of Duty: Modern Warfare. Therefore, SPOILERS AHEAD! You have been warned.
In all of the great stories throughout time, the protagonist seems to be doomed to suffer some sort of adversity in which they are powerless to prevent destiny from striking down a friend, mentor, sidekick, or companion. It's no surprise that in story-driven games, players now have to suffer the same misfortune and stand impotently by as characters they have grown up with or fought alongside, are subject to an irrevocable twist of fate.

In this list, we have decided to look at those characters that, despite everything, the player was always powerless to save from whatever fate ultimately befell them.

In putting the list together, it would have been easy to re-visit some of the past tear-jerker moments as a number of those involved characters meeting untimely ends. However, to avoid repetition, we have decided to stay away from those titles and stories, and come up with a list that is little different.

#5. Sgt. Paul Jackson - Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

In the usual blockbuster style CoD mission, the player was given the assignment to rescue a downed pilot. After the mission was completed, there was a mad rush to make it to the safety of the evacuation helicopter. As the chopper takes off, the player turns just in time to see a nuclear explosion behind them. The ensuing blast wave shocks the chopper into a terminal spin and sends it crashing. In the final moments, the player can only crawl from the wreckage with the sound of ragged breathing in the background, control is relinquished, and the screen fades to black as Jackson finally succumbs. No act of god, and no last minute reprieve. This time the player's character is KIA. For most, encountering the demise of Sgt. Jackson it was a defining and memorable "what the … ???" moment.



#4. Joe Barbaro - Mafia II

Without Joe Barbaro there wouldn't be Mafia 2. Joe's role was pivotal throughout the game in a number of key moments. It was Joe that introduced the players character, Vito Scaletta, to a life of crime after returning to a debt-ridden family towards the end of WWII. Vito and Joe rise through the ranks, and together become "made-men" in the Falcone family. Whilst Vito is a thoughtful and careful character, Joe is the hot-headed character living his mafia lifestyle to the fullest. Inevitably, Joe's rashness instigates a war between the local triads and mafia families and leaves the pair caught up in the midst of it all. This one moment seals Joe's fate and after the completion of the final shootout, Joe and Vito are driven away to celebrate their success with Vito in the limousine and Joe in the car behind. During the closing cinematic, the player is powerless and can only watch as the car carrying Joe turns off on a different route. Vito is simply told that "Joe wasn't part of our deal". Although Joe's fate is not actually seen, given that the car is heading to a previous burial ground and the dramatic way that the message is delivered, it can be assumed it was not going to end well for Joe. Having lived a Mafioso life, Joe ultimately suffered a typical Mafioso death.



#3. Spartan-B312 aka Noble Six - Halo: Reach

In Halo: Reach, the Spartans of Noble squad were making a stand for the sake of not only one planet or colony, but the whole of the human race. Whilst the fate of the planet Reach was well known to fans of Halo, the exact details were not, and players took the role of Spartan-B312 aka Noble Six in a mission to save Dr. Halsey and the precious cargo that is the key to the future survival of humanity. Over the course of the game's campaign, the members of Noble squad pay the ultimate price as one by one they fall in combat. In the end, the player is left as the only remaining squad member on the planet, making a desperate last man stand against the ever increasing numbers of covenant troops. Despite the best and most gallant of attempts, the player is overrun, eventually falling under a multitude of Energy Sword blades. The end scene shows the soldier’s battle marked helmet on grass with a brief eulogy reminding the player of the importance and significance of their sacrifice.




#2. The Joker - Batman: Arkham City

In the final showdown of Batman: Arkham City, the fatal disease that Joker contracted through the abuse of Titan finally catches up with him. His plan to save himself using a Lazarus Pit has been foiled by Batman, and the remaining vial of serum is broken when Joker himself attacks Batman. Cleverly written, it is the Joker's own actions that condemn him to his fate. The player (as Batman) is not given the chance to save him. In the final scene, the last dialog between the age old adversaries is reminiscent of the comics and the film, highlighting the strange relationship between hero and foe. Watching Batman carry Joker's body left many fans in denial, waiting for the next caper, waiting for a punch line that never came. For a title that many gamers and fans considered integral to the franchise, to kill off the arch-nemesis was seen as a bold and surprising storyline.



#1. Wheatley - Portal 2

Wheatley stole hearts and stole the show when he burst onto the scene in Portal 2. The lovable little robot provided the comic relief and some of the most memorable moments throughout the game. However, over the course of events, Wheatley takes over the system that had been vacated by GLaDOS and begins to succumb to her latent influence. In a case of absolute power corruption, Wheatley loses his affable bumbling character and becomes a new GLaDOS inspired antagonist. The player remains powerless to prevent the corruption and can only watch as Wheatley descends into a homicidal overseer, subjecting Chell to new "Wheatley Science" tests. In the final battle, Chell manages to pry Wheatley from GLaDOS’ system and the two are ejected through a portal to the moon’s surface. Removed from the core influence, we see the former personality return. Sadly, before the player has a chance to welcome back the restored Wheatley, GLaDOS knocks him from Chell's hands and sends him spinning into space. For those that hung around after the credits, we see a truly repentant Wheatley floating helplessly in space, fully back to his old self and yet sadly beyond salvation from the player.



Honorable Mentions
Dark Ones - Metro 2033 / Metro: Last Light
At the end of Metro 2033 the player is faced with the choice of saving or wiping out the colony of the aliens known only as 'The Dark Ones'. Those that had already read the book knew the correct decision to make, saving the aliens. However, at the start of Metro: Last Light the decision had been taken out of the players hands, and the story continued with the alien community having been decimated through a nuclear explosion.

Alcatraz - Crysis 2 / Crysis 3
At the start of Crysis 2 the player takes on the role of a stricken soldier, Alcatraz, who is rescued and subsequently sealed into the game's iconic nanosuit by the character, Prophet. Eventually, as the story reaches its climax, the player realises that they were not quite who, or what, they thought they were.

So these are the top five and the honorable mentions, but who did we miss? Who were the ones that you couldn't save?

The TA Team will be bringing you The TA Top Five every Sunday until we run out of coolness to debate and discuss. If you have an idea for a Top Five you'd like us to do, be sure to let us know in the comments!
AuthorMessage
Halcyon Pure
125,524
Halcyon Pure
125,524 TrueAchievement Points8 posts
Last post: 22 May at 21:58
Posted on 29 September 13 at 13:39
Honourable mention for me must go to Mordin Solus, who, in my playthrough of Mass Effect 3, chose to sacrifice himself to save the rest of us.

Not ashamed to admit I was choking back the tears as he hummed a little tune, bravely giving his life for our party; a character I had spent many, many, hours with by that time. Felt like I was losing a friend. :(

Fantastic story-telling from a fantastic franchise.
Boldewin
33,640
Boldewin - Working on Plants vs Zombies and Diablo on xbox one and counter strike on 360
33,640 TrueAchievement Points12 posts
Last post: 07 Jun at 12:56
Posted on 29 September 13 at 13:43
Well wouldn't Wheatly be at the moon held by it's gravity so it wouldn't be impossible to save him. Who knows he might be back in portal 3 if there is one.
MuscularTea
291,113
MuscularTea - Going over my Dragon Age playthroughs... I'm a ruthless motherfucker... Slept with everyone and murdered everyone.
291,113 TrueAchievement PointsTrueAchievement Ratio: 1.6421179 posts
Last post: 24 Aug at 16:49
Posted on 29 September 13 at 13:48
Dominic Santiago.... That is all.
Crimson Ravens!
Senior Chupon
184,255
Senior Chupon - An achievement a day keeps the doctor away.
347 solutionsTrueAchievements Game Info Editor3,919 posts
Last post: Today at 19:36
Posted on 29 September 13 at 13:50, Edited on 29 September 13 at 14:01 by Senior Chupon
Bill in Left 4 Dead 2
John Marston in RDR
Crono in Chrono Trigger*
Eli Vance in Half Life 2
Agro in Shadow of the Colossus
Johnny in To The Moon (also saddest game ever)
Andrew Ryan in Bioshock
Aerith in FF VII
Roalnd in Borderlands 2
Jin Uzuki in Xenosaga Episode III

*sort of

And then there are some that are determinate. there are quite a few deaths in the ME universe that are tough.

Thane (always dies in ME3)
Mordin (Most people probably see him die, but it's possible to save him in ME3)
Legion/Tali in ME3
Roman in GTA IV
Meryl in MGS (not canon, but ... damn)
Senior Chupon
184,255
Senior Chupon - An achievement a day keeps the doctor away.
347 solutionsTrueAchievements Game Info Editor3,919 posts
Last post: Today at 19:36
Posted on 29 September 13 at 13:51
Halcyon Pure said:Honourable mention for me must go to Mordin Solus, who, in my playthrough of Mass Effect 3, chose to sacrifice himself to save the rest of us.

Not ashamed to admit I was choking back the tears as he hummed a little tune, bravely giving his life for our party; a character I had spent many, many, hours with by that time. Felt like I was losing a friend. :(

Fantastic story-telling from a fantastic franchise.
Yea I was pretty shocked to find there is a way to save him. I almost thought it was universal that he had to die, but turns out there's a specific set of choices that can save him.
vSully
250,232
vSully - Does anyone know for sure if I'll auto-pop all the achievements  from 360 just by loading the Xbone version of Destiny?
Achievement Completion Percentage: 99.83% (Includes owned DLC) - 5 more achievements required to reach 99.9%TrueAchievement Ratio: 1.8839716 posts
Last post: Today at 15:00
Posted on 29 September 13 at 13:52, Edited on 29 September 13 at 13:53 by vSully
MuscularTea said:Dominic Santiago.... That is all.My first and only thought upon seeing the article title.

Then I thought a little more and came up with Roland in Borderlands 2.

*shrug*
Akatsuki 19XX - There's blood on the walls, blood on the walls, and it seems so unreal.
93,348 TrueAchievement Points136 posts
Last post: 13 Aug at 12:10
Posted on 29 September 13 at 13:59
No Dom from Gears 3? Not even in the honorable mentions?!

That's ridiculous.
Masta Skor 16
123,178
Masta Skor 16 - Looking for a coop partner for Halo:ODST and/or Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary, anyone ?
123,178 TrueAchievement Points236 posts
Last post: 11 Mar at 18:39
Posted on 29 September 13 at 14:15
vSully said:MuscularTea said:Dominic Santiago.... That is all.My first and only thought upon seeing the article title.

Then I thought a little more and came up with Roland in Borderlands 2.

*shrug*
THis !!
elKazaam
46,786
elKazaam
28 completed games(Includes owned DLC)TrueAchievement Ratio: 1.5846212 posts
Last post: 04 Sep at 13:22
Posted on 29 September 13 at 14:39
Wheatley - Portal 2 is not realy dead, just lost...
and will there be ever a 3rd portal, wheatly will come back, you will see.
CHIGGUMS
91,784
CHIGGUMS - Whoever wrote the achievement list for Trials of Dunwall needs to be castrated and launched into the sun.
Achievement Completion Percentage: 99.64% (Includes owned DLC) - 2 more achievements required to reach 99.7%49 completed games(Includes owned DLC)256 posts
Last post: Today at 18:10
Posted on 29 September 13 at 14:39, Edited on 29 September 13 at 14:40 by CHIGGUMS
I feel much less strongly about the "good guys I wasn't able to save" article than the "assholes I wasn't able to kill" article.

I wonder what that says about me. (Answer: too much)
olde fortran 77 - ---
152,897 TrueAchievement Points1,378 votes218 posts
Last post: 21 Nov at 19:04
Posted on 29 September 13 at 14:44
George In Halo Reach seemed like a nice guy. He was the only one I'd miss.
I have a pathetically high tolerance for grinding.
ll HYS7ERIA ll - SHADES DOWN BRO. THE NEON ICON ALBUM IS OFF THE CHAIN.
Achievement Completion Percentage: 59.44% (Includes owned DLC) - 49 more achievements required to reach 60%35 completed games(Includes owned DLC)747 posts
Last post: 21 Nov at 22:53
Posted on 29 September 13 at 14:46, Edited on 29 September 13 at 21:58 by ll HYS7ERIA ll
Carmine brothers -Gears of War 1 & 2
Tai - Gears of War 2
Dom - Gears of War 3
John Marston - Red Dead Redemption
Ghost - Call of Duty MW2
Roach - Call of Duty MW2
Soap - Call of Duty MW3
Chen - F.E.A.R. Perseus Mandate Campaign of F.E.A.R. Files
Think before you speak.
PrinzHintz
280,823
PrinzHintz
280,823 TrueAchievement Points85 posts
Last post: 22 Nov at 19:36
Posted on 29 September 13 at 14:49
John Marston.
TheBuddha336
521,315
TheBuddha336
TrueAchievement Site Rank: 573 out of 278,373187 completed games(Includes owned DLC)736 posts
Last post: 19 Nov at 18:37
Posted on 29 September 13 at 15:06
What about Lee in the walking dead ?

And I agree about Dom in gears of war 3
Confused Shelf - TA Pro has expired! Crazy to think it has been 2 years since I wrote my blog leaderboard.
115,304 TrueAchievement PointsTrueAchievement Site Rank: 38,859 out of 278,3733,264 posts
Last post: 22 Sep at 18:08
Posted on 29 September 13 at 15:16
As someone who barely skims through these, I'm laughing so much at the comments.

It seems to me that 80% of the community rips into the team that makes these for only picking from the six biggest game series for their top fives. Now they leave out some of the more obvious ones and people are outraged that they chose less successful games over the big releases.
"Revenge is a dish best served on a bed of rice."
Unfcnbleevibl
246,990
Unfcnbleevibl - Finally hit the point in EDF 2025 that I need to farm armor. Gonna be a long boring grind for a while.
246,990 TrueAchievement PointsTrueAchievement Site Rank: 6,785 out of 278,3734,878 posts
Last post: Yesterday at 02:33
Posted on 29 September 13 at 15:17
Just from 360 games, I would have had:

Roland from Borderlands 2
Dom from Gears 3
Tai from Gears 2
Seth from Lost Odyssey
G O I7ofL 1 V E - SERIOUSLY 3.0: 60/65. HORDE, BEAST, ARCADE, & WEAPON ONYX MEDALS COMPLETED. LATEST- WINGMAN
Achievement Completion Percentage: 95.01% (Includes owned DLC) - 41 more achievements required to reach 96%151 completed games(Includes owned DLC)514 posts
Last post: 23 Nov at 05:32
Posted on 29 September 13 at 15:23
gamer=TheBuddha336]What about Lee in the walking dead ?

Lee's in my top 5.

The CoD 4 mission mentioned above was a tough one on veteran.
Riconoclast
466,820
Riconoclast - Shining Empire just revitalised my interest in 360.
466,820 TrueAchievement Points3,029 posts
Last post: 04 May at 18:43
Posted on 29 September 13 at 15:25
No love for Wrex from Mass Effect? Or some of the characters in the stories from Lost Odyssey?
Senior Chupon
184,255
Senior Chupon - An achievement a day keeps the doctor away.
347 solutionsTrueAchievements Game Info Editor3,919 posts
Last post: Today at 19:36
Posted on 29 September 13 at 15:53
Riconoclast said:No love for Wrex from Mass Effect? Or some of the characters in the stories from Lost Odyssey?Wrex isn't one that you can't save. His death is determinate.