I ended up playing a game just to try and get this. It only took about 10 questions to get it but it was very tricky.
There seems to be some lag between the time you press the button and when the point counter stops which is to be expected, so you actually need to press the button the corresponds with the correct answer when the Points read about 7 or 8 points (if you can actually see the number.)
Personally I couldn't really see the numbers so I kind of had to guess the proper timing. 0 will most likely be the number of points you get while trying for this achievement because of the time it takes the game to register the button press, but don't give up!
EDIT: As XanthicAntimony pointed out in the comments, the point meter goes slower in the Match-up style questions. Thanks for the tip!