The most sure way to get one of the 3 stars of the game is to have a high point total. You don't need to score all of the goals, so you can do this with a playmaker, or a sniper. This is easiest to accomplish when you are playing against a team with a user controlled goalie, as they tend to make more mistakes. When setting up your team, make sure you assign yourself as either captain or assistant captain. You will know during the game, because you will have either a 'C' or an 'A' on your jersey.
Note: THIS ACHIEVEMENT CANNOT BE OBTAINED WHILE GOALTENDING.