Finishing a Madden Moment will net you this achievement. You have to complete the objective of the Madden moment to unlock the achievement. ANY Madden Moment you choose to play will net you the achievement so long as you achieve the goal of the Madden Moment.
"They did it again" is only 3 star difficulty
you simply have to beat the Patriots with the Giants and win the Super Bowl. You have roughly 4 mins to win the game. If you score a touchdown with Victor Cruz you will also net the "pass the salsa" achievement.
Edit: You no longer need the online pass confimed by crimson nutcase