Scroll through all of the elements you have for each of your four powers (elements are given through side quests). This achievement is possible after completing the side quests for Benjamin King; this will give you the lightning and freeze element for Buff. Once inside Virtual Steelport, press the d-pad in each direction several times to select each element for each power.
Disclaimer: I taken zero credit in this guide, I am merely copying the american versions guides for people with the Australian version because it is more convenient for them.