This one is easy even with just one controller. If you are in no hurry, just set the time limit to 15 or 20 minutes and take yourself a good NHL team and choose a team from AHL, elite series or sm-liiga against you. You should be able to shoot at least 25 time in the first period, after that you can start hunting the penalty kill special achievement. Just keep slashing opponents players until you are 2 men down, and then try to get a goal. Quite easy 75 points at the same time.