You can do this using the ol' "two controller" method.
Start a game using two controllers in play now. Set to superstar, shortest periods possible. the trick is to not OVERPLAY, your opponent won't be doing much so just score with 3 seperate players on your time.
Get the puck and then pull the opposing teams goalie. Shoot and score with 3 different players and then spend the rest of the time as idle as you can, clock should run out soon... The trick here is to NEVER shoot on the goalie! If the goalie makes some good saves then he will be a star of the game also!