This requires you to win the Shootout Minigame without missing.
For shooting I would generally aim for the bottom left or right corner. I only had the keeper stop this shot 1 time out of roughly 20 attempts on Beginner.
To end Minigame after only 3 shots you can try to block all 3 shots (also an achievement). To do this I picked my opponent to be a 2 Star team and simply kept my goalie in the middle as they kicked it there pretty often as well as flat out missed a lot. This does require a bit of luck.