37 0 11**THIS ACHIEVEMENT IS MISSABLE**This one is quite easy! You just need to ensure you take the time to interact with Toby at least once during every case. Toby can always be found back in Sherlock's living room. Sometimes in front of the windows, other times on the couch. Just approach him and hit A to have Sherlock talk to him and you're done for that particular case.During Case 2, "Off the Rails!" you MUST interact with Toby at the start of the case as you will NOT have the chance to return to Baker Street once you set off for your journey.Guide not helping? View 1 more guide for this achievement.Showing most recent comments. View all comments. can i just load up a case, interact with him and quit out of it?Posted by imoneoldfart on 12 Jun 17 at 15:41 yes you can just load up a case and get the ones you missed. i missed toby in case 2 and loaded it up after finishing the story and the achievement popped right away.Posted by KilldbyNecropsy on 06 Aug 17 at 22:50 Thank you imoneoldfart! Glad I don't have to replay the whole game...Posted by ICE Faux Pirate on 10 Jun 20 at 02:23 Leave a comment