1. Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments Achievements
2. I Never Guess achievement

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

1,583

1,000

25

3.51

52,320

10,103 (19%)

12-15h

Lists

• Sign in or sign up to start making your own lists.

•  Create a list

Game

• 33 want to boost

I Never Guess achievement in Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments

I Never Guess

Reach 6 correct conclusions for all 6 cases.

0

1 guide

How to unlock the I Never Guess achievement

• garageparty

  09 Mar 2016 06 Mar 2016
  29 0 4

  Actions

  • Report Solution

  *** Spoiler - click to reveal ***Case 1: Cairns is guilty
  Case 2: Mexicans drowned Chileans
  Case 3: Blinkhorn (ice knife)
  Case 4: The Captain is the killer
  Case 5: White is an accomplice
  Case 6: Foley's vengeance

  
  
  The achievement doesn't pop until after the credits after the last case, so don't panic when it doesn't pop right after the last cutscene.
  @Stavia
  -----------------------------------------------
  The moral choice doesn't matter for this achievement. Simply choosing the correct person is what is important.
  @HolyWarr27
  -----------------------------------------------

  Showing all 4 comments. Leave a comment.

  does this have to be done in one playthru or can you just replay the cases you messed up?

  Posted by lunatic1sick7 on 06 Apr 16 at 10:54

  Replay works fine

  Posted by x ZiiiG x on 02 May 16 at 03:03

  It didn't pop for me even-though i used the guide on ta

  Posted by dementeddeer89 on 13 May 16 at 20:04

  I tried to replay a case and got the right conclusion, watched the credits and still nothing. Am I going to have to do an entirely new playthrough? :/

  Posted by Slurm Queen on 07 Sep 18 at 20:31

  Leave a comment

• Have you got any tips or tricks to unlock this achievement?
  Add a guide to share them with the community.

  Add a guide