First of all, this solution is for those who have already completed Episode 2 and noticed that this achievement did not unlock.
If you have not finished this episode yet this is not the solution for you.Allow me by starting with a list of the achievements that did not unlock for me before I realized some did not pop as they should have: (I was nearly complete with Episode 4)
Episode 1Now What?
Episode 2New Morning
Old friends
Episode 3Fresh Fish
Not in Nottingham
I can't guarantee that the following choices between the "New Morning" achievement and the "Old friends" achievement effects it later on but I am documenting them here anyways just in case. (There are 4 achievements before "Old Friends" would pop)
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***Picking up immediately where we left off from popping "New Morning" ...
>You can trust me
>Sure.
>QTE take picture of Sarah
>He'll be fine
>Go hide
>*Open door knob
>Clementine
>Come in
>We have a big group
>That's a lot of people to lose
>I'm just passing through
>Have you met anyone named Christa?
>Over there
>What happened to him?
>It's probably the wind
>Well it's a kid
>They're my friends
>Pete trusted me
>Who are you?
**"The Intruder" achievement should have popped at this point**
>I didn't open the door!
>I don't remember!
>He was wearing a brown coat
>I took the picture
>What does he want?
**"Left the Cabin" achievement should have popped at this point**
>Why is Carver after you?
>He wanted to see you.
>Yeah I'm with you guys
>looked at landmarks from left to right, starting with the bridge.
>I can do it
>Safety?
>Family?
>I don't want to upset her
>What do you think?
>I've got the small one
>Went for the big one
>QTE to get hammer out of walker
**"Over the Bridge" achievement should have popped at this point**
>I missed QTE for reach for the dude lol
>QTE for walker #1
>QTE to pull up self on bridge
>QTE to kill walker #2
>QTE to give stick to Nick
>What should I say?
>We're a little lost
>We're just people
>Do you know Carver?
>[GRAB GUN]
>Is anyone hurt?
**"A Stanger" achievement should have popped at this point**
The next achievement that should unlock is "Old Friends", here are the choices for a guaranteed pop:
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***
>Everybody calm down
>I don't know
>Sure.
>*Went straight to walking inside building
>*Grab survival knife off counter
>*Open chest with knife
>*Grab beans
>Give him a break.
>A woman in our group
>Rebecca can have it
>I had a treehouse once.
>*climb up ladder
>You just told me not to look!
>*climb ladder again
>*look at bridge
>*look at light
>*climb down ladder
>Kenny?!
>[HUG KENNY]
Achievement should pop. Please comment if this worked for you. I will see you next in Episode 3 for the attempt at popping "Fresh Fish". I went to the main menu as soon as I popped "Old Friends" & started up Episode 3.