(THIS ACHIEVEMENT CAN BE GOTTEN IN THE FREE TRIAL)
I got this one in two tries and I am by no means adept at these type of puzzles!
I got it on the first seek puzzle in the game, right after finding the keys and looking at a photograph.
The items are ALWAYS random except for the angel head which is a 'key item'.
Familiarize yourself with the items a bit and feel free to use the 'hint' by hitting Up on the d-pad.
-It was my inclination to make an image map but cross referencing that with the puzzle was too time intensive and your short term memory should be quicker.
-If you fail and you may the first couple times, exit out start a new game (you can skip cutscenes) and this is NOT as tedious as it sounds at all because it might as well be a checkpoint, it's at the beginning of the game. I genuinely hope this helps! I know it would have saved me time :\