Easy way to get this is with 2 controllers.
Do Play Now, 1 min qtrs, Rookie.
Play the game for the first 3 qtrs and keep it scoreless. You can use the chew clock option on offense to make it go faster but make sure you turn it off for the 4th qtr.
When the 4th qtr starts, make sure you get the ball to the active controller for your profile. If that profile does not have the ball, use the 2nd controller to punt the ball away.
Once you have possession with the active profile, drive the ball to fg range. Best way to do this is to pick Hail Mary on offense with the active controller and punt block on defense with the second controller.
Throw the ball to any receiver as they will be wide open, but don't score. Get down to the 20 yard line or closer so you can kick an easy field goal. IMPORTANT : Don't go out of bounds and don't call a time out. Just get tackled in the middle of the field and let the clock run.
Now with the other controller, call a time out with 3 seconds left in the game. If you did it correctly, when you line up for the game winning field goal with the active controller/profile, the camera will be zoomed in and the kick meter will be double the size.
Just kick the fg and the achievement will pop.