There have been new crafting recipes since the last solutions were written, plus some other changes to the game, so I feel like a new solution overhauling everything is needed. This solution is based on the 1.5.4.1 version released on February 15, 2021. In the event that there is a newer version at the time you read this, you can compare your list of items against the one here:
http://stardewvalleywiki.com/Craftingto see if anything is missing.
I have tried to keep spoilers to a minimum, but unfortunately, it is impossible to explain all of this without giving some spoilers.
PREREQUISITES
Before you can craft every item, you must have acquired every crafting recipe and have unlocked access to every required material. This is the real challenge in unlocking the achievement; collecting materials and using the crafting menu is just busy work. Below are the tasks or milestones you must complete before you can obtain all of the crafting recipes and materials. Some recipes are learned instantly, others arrive in the mail, and others must be purchased in a shop that unlocks when you complete the milestone. If you complete a milestone below and don't automatically get a crafting recipe from doing it, then keep exploring and look for a new shop that just opened up.
If you're unable to complete some of these prerequisites because you don't even know what they refer to, keep working on the prerequisites you are able to. Everything will come together in due time.
SkillsReach Combat Level 9
Reach Farming level 9
Reach Fishing Level 9
Reach Foraging level 9
Reach Mining Level 9
MuseumDonate an ancient seed to the musuem
Donate four dwarf scrolls to the museum
Donate a total of 60 items to the museum
SocialWitness Caroline's 2-heart event
Witness Linus's 4-heart event
Witness Gus's 5-heart event
Witness Robin's 6-heart event
Witness Krobus's 3-heart event
Special OrdersFulfill the "Community Cleanup" special order (Linus)
Fulfill the "Juicy Bugs Wanted" special order (Willy)
Fulfill the "Island Ingredients" special order (Caroline)
Fulfill the "Fragments of the Past" special order (Gunther)
Fulfill the "Cave Patrol" special order (Clint)
Fulfill the "Robin's Resource Rush" special order (Robin)
Fulfill the "A Curious Substance" special order (Wizard)
Fulfill either the "Aquatic Overpopulation" or "Biome Balance" special order (Demetrius)
Ginger IslandObtain 100 walnuts
Purchase the island farmhouse
Purchase the trading hut
Reach level 5 of the volcano dungeon
Complete the Island Field Office collection
Complete "The Pirate's Wife" quest
Perform the "Skull Cavern Invasion" or "Danger in the Deep" quest
OtherComplete the third farmhouse upgrade (cellar)
Complete all Community Center bundles or Community Development forms
Repair Willy's boat
Complete "The Mysterious Qi" quest
Collect all 8 rarecrows
*Visit the Traveling cart in a multiplayer game
*NOT required in single player, but obtainable anyway. You can solo it, but you need two controllers. You DON'T need two XBox Live accounts. Build a cabin on your farm. This building has instant construction, so if it's Friday or Sunday, you can proceed immediately to the next step, which is to switch on local co-op in the Settings menu. Use your second controller to create a new playable character. As soon as that character joins the map, the crafting recipe you need will appear in the traveling cart. Buy it and then return to single player.
SHOPS
Pierre's general store
Robin
Traveling cart (Cindersap Forest, Fri & Sun)
Pierre's Flower Dance store Spring 24
Star token store Fall 16
Pierre's Sprit's Eve store Fall 27
Traveling merchant cart Winter 8
Night market Winter 15-17
Desert trader
Casino
Krobus
Dwarf (mines)
Dwarf (volcano)
Island trader
Mr Qi's walnut hut
Some shops must be visited several times. Notoriously, you must go back to Robin again and again and again, buying 1 crafting recipe at a time, until until she runs out. Also pay special attention to visiting the festival shops, both for crafting recipes and rarecrows.
INGREDIENTS
The crafting menu shows you the ingredients you need. I don't think it's necessary to list every ingredient in the solution. Instead, here's what you're most likely to be short of, and where to get it:
Hardwood - Replenished daily in the Secret Forest
Iridium ore - Raise your evaluation from Grandpa to "4 candles" and pick up the Statue of Perfection from his shrine the following day. Before long, you'll have more iridium ore than you can use. See more here:
http://stardewvalleywiki.com/Grandpa Solar essence - buy from Krobus
Void essence - buy from Krobus
CRAFTING
You don't need to keep track of which items you've crafted or keep them in chests; the game does that for you. Simply pick "Show Advanced Crafting Options" in the Settings menu, and voila. Putting your resource chests next to a workbench and crafting at the workbench saves you from having to put everything in your backpack.
If you don't want all this junk you'll be making, buy a Deconstructor from Mr. Qi first and toss things into it after you've made them. This could also help your resources stretch further.