For those of you who get the majority of your wickets with run outs and bowl outs, the catches will come less naturally.
In order to force the ball to hit a glove or bat and be caught, I found the best method to be using a 2nd controller for the batter and a fast/medium bowler for the achievement earner.
With the second controller move the batter across to cover the stumps.
The achievement earner will want to set up fielders in the slips positions to cover all small knicks and touches of the bat. With the bowler, send a "Short ball" down the wicket, (Bouncers work too, but you are limited to 2 an over and after the two any others are No Balls and will result in no wicket) then with the secondary controller try and time a late hit, Either
. Late timing will result in either you punching the ball or clipping it, doing so with this timing will send the ball either straight up for a reflex catch
or straight to a fielder for an auto catch.
It may take a few attempts to get, but it will pop immediately upon the third catch.