About 16% of the way through the Longshot mode, you will be playing a flashback game vs Katy. The second part of this game is a punt return that you have to return for a touchdown. If you fail to do so, press
for "Tell it again!" and you can keep retrying as many times as you need. Don't press
to "Move on" or you will miss the opportunity for this achievement and have to start Longshot over again to get it.