1. Tell Me Why Achievements
  2. Fish all the Fish achievement
Tell Me Why

Tell Me Why

Xbox Game Pass
2,072
1,500
30
3.59
Game
Tell Me Why
Grimslinger19

Grimslinger19

1,400
1,100
21
19 Jan 21
70%
Grimslinger19
Add-on

Chapter 3: Inheritance

761
500
10
3.59
21,680
6,088 (28%)
3-4 h
Chapter 3: Inheritance

Fish all the Fish achievement in Tell Me Why

Fish all the Fish

Catch all the fish with Michael

Fish all the Fish-0.1
24 January 2021 - 4 guidesOffline Game ModeSingle Player
Tell Me Why walkthrough

How to unlock the Fish all the Fish achievement

  • The CherishedThe Cherished800,813
    10 Sep 2020 10 Sep 2020 10 Sep 2020
    33 0 4
    Missable achievement.

    Shortly after you unlock the story-related "Are You My Daddy" achievement, you will switch to playing as Tyler. After a bit of talking, you will go ice fishing with Michael.

    To unlock the achievement, you must catch THREE fish while talking to him. It is done via a very easy mini game of holding down the Left Trigger to keep a cursor within a sweet spot, and then simply holding down Right Trigger. You'll have to switch between these buttons about three times each mini game.

    After catching the third fish this will unlock. If you happen to miss a fish, you can replay via chapter select.

    Guide not helping? View 3 more guides for this achievement.

    Showing most recent comments. View all comments.
    K000ZZ3rd fish glitched for me. Got to blue spot, but never prompted to hold rt.
    Posted by K000ZZ on 07 Oct 20 at 14:52
    LordVespucciI tought mine didn't pop but it secretly unlocked. So check your Achievements tab :)
    Posted by LordVespucci on 08 Oct 20 at 16:12
    Northern LassI caught the three fish but this didn't pop for me until I started replaying for the alternative ending achievements.
    Posted by Northern Lass on 06 Feb at 19:47

  • Have you got any tips or tricks to unlock this achievement?
    Add a guide to share them with the community.

    Sign in and add a guide
  • ARAFF200ARAFF200660,879
    11 Sep 2020 11 Sep 2020 11 Sep 2020
    6 0 0
    During the mission chosen family, you will be ice fishing with Michael! Each time you can catch a fish there will be a prompt to click the A button then you will play a little mini game to reel it in! Just make sure you catch all 3 fish and you'll get the achievement!

    This achievement is pretty hard to miss, but if your still confused here is a video guide with all the chapter 3 related achievements and collectibles! The Fish All The Fish Achievement Starts at 3:03! Timestamps for the other achievements and collectibles are in the description!

  • UntilTammaroYTUntilTammaroYT236,860
    12 Sep 2020 13 Sep 2020 13 Sep 2020
    5 1 0


    In the chapter 'Chosen Family', you will be fishing with Michael on the frozen lake. You will be having a conversation throughout this entire time. Make sure to pay attention to the fishing rod as you will be given a timed prompt to catch a fish. You will only have three opportunities, so you can't miss one. Once fishing, you just need to hold the left trigger into the sweet spot and then hold the right trigger to reel in the fish. You can replay any section of the Episode in Isolation mode without overwriting your story progress.
There is 1 other guide for this achievement
Do you have a question about this achievement? Please post it in the Tell Me Why Forum

Related Achievements

Item Guides Top Guide
Tell Me Why Fish all the Fish achievement Fish all the Fish achievement in Tell Me Why (PC) 0