Simple achievement and very quick to complete.
This can be done in any game mode but my solution is for people that are going for this achievement only.
Start a local match playing as a high star team vs a low star team. I chose Manchester Blue vs Luton WO (English 2nd Division).
Match Level - Beginner
Match Time - 5 min.
Condition Home - Positive
Condition Away - Negative
Keep the game level during the full 90 minutes. During the 2nd half stop play several times by kicking the ball out of play or fouling your opposition, this will ensure you have enough time added onto stoppage time. Once the clock reaches stoppage time (90+ minutes) just score a goal and win the game. With these settings on it makes this achievement easy.