Mafia Definitive Edition has a total of 172 collectibles - 50 Mystery Foxes, 22 Cigarette Cards,
20 Dime Detectives, 20 Black Masks, 20 Super Science Stories, 20 Terror Tales, 10 Gangsters Monthly, 5 Post Cards and 5 Hidden Cars
You need all of them for various achievements. Fortunately, none of them can be missed. There are two types of collectibles, story and free roam collectibles. Story collectibles only spawn and collectable during the story.
These collectibles can you pick up every time via chapter select. All collectibles are immediately saved. Free roam collectibles are of course available in Free roam which is called Free Ride and in the story too! This mode unlock after chapter 2 or 3.
In the story you can also find a lot of available free roam collectibles close to the story. If you follow my story video, you will have collected 81 of the 172 collectibles at the end. The remaining 91 collectibles are in the seperate free roam video guide.
Story CollectiblesTimeline: (LARGE!!)
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***Chapter 3 - Molotov Party
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***00:00 - 01 - Cigarette Card #02 - Paulie Lombardo
00:32 - 02 - Dime Detective #14 - Death Wears Red Heels
00:48 - 03 - Super Science #14 - The Black Sun Rises
01:12 - 04 - Super Science #01 - Day of the Comet
01:28 - 05 - Mystery Fox #01
Chapter 4 - Ordinary Routine
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***01:47 - 06 - Cigarette Card #03 - Sam Trapani
02:27 - 07 - Dime Detective #12 - Hayseed Homicide
02:52 - 08 - Gangsters Monthly #07 - An Offer You Can’t Refuse
03:09 - 09 - Mystery Fox #02
Chapter 5 - Fair Play
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***03:34 - 10 - Black Mask #16 - A Crashing G Man Story
03:56 - 11 - Cigarette Card #07 - Luigi Marino
04:16 - 12 - Dime Detective #09 - Death Blows out the Candles
Chapter 7 - Better Get Used to It
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***04:39 - 13 - Dime Detective #06 - Happy Murder to You!
04:57 - 14 - Gangsters Monthly #08 - The Racing Racketeer
05:13 - 15 - Super Science #16 - The Brain Beast
05:36 - 16 - Cigarette Card #19 - Lou Marcano
05:56 - 17 - Mystery Fox #03
Chapter 8 - The Saint and The Sinner
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***06:15 - 18 - Mystery Fox #04
06:42 - 19 - Black Mask #02 - Race Williams Never Bluffs
07:00 - 20 - Black Mask #17 - Red Death
07:22 - 21 - Dime Detective #13 - Mexican Slayride
07:59 - 22 - Cigarette Card #14 - Leo Galante
08:28 - 23 - Gangsters Monthly #09 - Sarah Moll on a Mission
09:04 - 24 - Dime Detective #19 - The Lady’s From Hades
09:28 - 25 - Dime Detective #18 - Live and Let Die
09:41 - 26 - Cigarette Card #13 - Frank Vinci
Chapter 9 - A Trip to the Country
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***10:00 - 27 - Cigarette Card #12 - Carlo Falcone
10:27 - 28 - Dime Detective #11 - Weather Fair Track Bloody
10:54 - 29 - Mystery Fox #05
11:19 - 30 - Terror Tales #20 - All These Must Die!
11:38 - 31 - Cigarette Card #22 - Sammy Robinson
11:51 - 32 - Super Science #17 - Minus Danger!
12:05 - 33 - Black Mask #05 - The Flame
Chapter 10 - Omerta
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***12:28 - 34 - Dime Detective #20 - Death Gives A Permanent Wave
12:49 - 35 - Mystery Fox #06
13:23 - 36 - Black Mask #08 - The Deal
13:45 - 37 - Terror Tales #18 - Mistress of the Dark Pool
14:12 - 38 - Mystery Fox #07
14:35 - 39 - Super Science #07 - Aerita of the Light County
15:00 - 40 - Cigarette Card #05 - Frank Colletti
15:33 - 41 - Gangsters Monthly #01 - A Trip to the Country
Chapter 11 - Visiting Rich People
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***16:05 - 42 - Super Science #10 - Prisoner of Time
16:23 - 43 - Cigarette Card #04 - Ennio Salieri
16:43 - 44 - Dime Detective #08 - You’re The Crime in my Coffee
17:00 - 45 - Mystery Fox #08
Chapter 12 - Great Deal
Chapter 13 - Bon Appétit
Chapter 14 - Happy Birthday
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***18:34 - 49 - Dime Detective #01 - Please Pass the Poison
19:00 - 50 - Cigarette Card #08 - Marcu Morello
19:35 - 51 - Super Science #08 - Tumithak of the Towers of Fire
20:08 - 52 - Mystery Fox #09
20:34 - 53 - Dime Detective #07 - You Can Die Any Day
Chapter 15 - You Lucky Bastard
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***20:58 - 54 - Cigarette Card #10 - Felice Peppone
21:22 - 55 - Terror Tales #15 - Slaves for the Wine Goddess
21:38 - 56 - Dime Detective #10 - A Horse of Another Killer
21:58 - 57 - Cigarette Card #09 - Sergio Morello
22:19 - 58 - Gangsters Monthly #10 - Steam Boys
22:40 - 59 - Mystery Fox #10
Chapter 16 - Crème de la Crème
Chapter 17 - Election Campaign
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***23:42 - 62 - Gangsters Monthly #04 - Jimmy’s Vendetta
24:18 - 63 - Dime Detective #05 - The Corpse That Wasn’t There
25:04 - 64 - Dime Detective #15 - Sealed with a Kris
25:30 - 65 - Mystery Fox #11
25:57 - 66 - Terror Tales #19 - My Sweetheart of Death
26:29 - 67 - Cigarette Card #06 - Vincenzo Ricci
Chapter 18 - Just for Relaxation
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***26:58 - 68 - Black Mask #04 - Soft City
27:24 - 69 - Dime Detective #16 - Feather Your Coffin
28:06 - 70 - Cigarette Card #11 - Tomaso Moretti
28:24 - 71 - Super Science #02 - Invisible One
Chapter 19 - Moonlighting
Chapter 20 - The Death of Art
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***29:49 - 74 - Cigarette Card #01 - Tommy Angelo
30:05 - 75 - Dime Detective #03 - Watch Me Kill You!
30:17 - 76 - Mystery Fox #12
30:35 - 77 - Gangsters Monthly #06 - Moonlighting
31:02 - 78 - Black Mask #14 - Death By Appointment
31:20 - 79 - Super Science #13 - Legion of the Dark
31:45 - 80 - Cigarette Card #18 - Valerio Marcano
32:09 - 81 - Terror Tales #17 - The Corpses Wedding Night
Free Roam CollectiblesTimeline: (LARGE!!)
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***01-15
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***00:00 - 01-05 - Post Cards (Unlock Hidden Cars)
01:05 - 06 - Mystery Fox #13
01:30 - 07 - Cigarette Card #17 - Giuseppe Carillo
01:50 - 08 - Black Mask #19 - Murder Goes to Market
02:12 - 09 - Mystery Fox #14
02:43 - 10 - Terror Tales #01 - House of Living Death
03:07 - 11 - Mystery Fox #15
03:33 - 12 - Hidden Car #01 - Manta Prototype
04:29 - 13 - Mystery Fox #16
04:54 - 14 - Mystery Fox #27
05:22 - 15 - Mystery Fox #18
16-30
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***05:49 - 16 - Black Mask #06 - A New Story of MacBride of Richmond City
06:15 - 17 - Mystery Fox #19
06:43 - 18 - Terror Tales #04 - Crawling Madness
07:09 - 19 - Mystery Fox #20
07:32 - 20 - Terror Tales #13 - Bride of the Serpent
07:54 - 21 - Gangsters Monthly #02 - All Saint’s Day Massacre
08:24 - 22 - Mystery Fox #21
08:51 - 23 - Super Science #06 - Mission Unknown
09:16 - 24 - Mystery Fox #22
09:43 - 25 - Terror Tales #08 - Brides For The Damned
10:07 - 26 - Mystery Fox #23
10:34 - 27 - Gangsters Monthly #03 - Beware the Hanoi Hangman
11:02 - 28 - Black Mask #10 - Save Your Tears
11:24 - 29 - Super Science #04 - Collision Course
11:46 - 30 - Super Science #05 - Genus Homo
31-45
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***12:14 - 31 - Mystery Fox #24
12:45 - 32 - Terror Tales #03 - When Love Went Mad!
13:11 - 33 - Mystery Fox #25
13:36 - 34 - Super Science #03 - Cepheid Planet
14:00 - 35 - Black Mask #18 - No Hard Feelings
14:19 - 36 - Black Mask #15 - Race Williams in Six Have Died
14:37 - 37 - Mystery Fox #26
15:05 - 38 - Super Science #18 - Outcast of the Stars
15:25 - 39 - Mystery Fox #27
15:49 - 40 - Hidden Car #02 - Flame Spear
16:17 - 41 - Cigarette Card #15 - Fredo Clemente
16:37 - 42 - Hidden Car #03 - Trautenberg Sport
17:44 - 43 - Mystery Fox #28
18:09 - 44 - Black Mask #07 - Walking Dynamite
18:34 - 45 - Mystery Fox #29
46-60
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***18:55 - 46 - Black Mask #20 - Flaming Angel
19:15 - 47 - Mystery Fox #30
19:35 - 48 - Super Science #19 - The Death Crystal
19:58 - 49 - Terror Tales #09 - Satan’s Love Bazaar
20:14 - 50 - Hidden Car #04 - Lassiter V16 Appolyon
20:42 - 51 - Black Mask #09 - Red Jade
21:07 - 52 - Mystery Fox #31
21:28 - 53 - Mystery Fox #32
21:49 - 54 - Black Mask #03 - The Farewell Murder
22:13 - 55 - Mystery Fox #33
22:35 - 56 - Terror Tales #07 - Brides For The Swamp God
22:56 - 57 - Super Science #09 - The Cross of Mercrux
23:20 - 58 - Mystery Fox #34
23:43 - 59 - Mystery Fox #35
24:03 - 60 - Terror Tales #06 - Thirst of the Damned
61-75
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***24:28 - 61 - Mystery Fox #36
25:05 - 62 - Black Mask #13 - Hunch
25:28 - 63 - Terror Tales #11 - Mistress of Satan’s Hounds
25:48 - 64 - Mystery Fox #37
26:09 - 65 - Mystery Fox #38
26:32 - 66 - Mystery Fox #39
26:56 - 67 - Black Mask #12 - Stag Party
27:23 - 68 - Mystery Fox #40
28:00 - 69 - Mystery Fox #41
28:18 - 70 - Gangsters Monthly #05 - The Mafia Three
76-End
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***29:14 - 71 - Black Mask #11 - A Woman Can Kill
29:37 - 72 - Cigarette Card #16 - Louie Romeo
29:57 - 73 - Mystery Fox #42
30:19 - 74 - Terror Tales #10 - Hostess For the Dying
30:39 - 75 - Super Science #15 - The Earth Killers
30:58 - 76 - Terror Tales #12 - Hell’s Station Master
31:18 - 77 - Mystery Fox #43
31:43 - 78 - Hidden Car #05 - Disorder
32:09 - 79 - Terror Tales #14 - The Man Who Loved a Zombie
32:31 - 80 - Terror Tales #02 - River of Pain
32:48 - 81 - Mystery Fox #44
33:13 - 82 - Mystery Fox #45
33:34 - 83 - Mystery Fox #46
33:56 - 84 - Mystery Fox #47
34:18 - 85 - Super Science #11 - Cham of the Hills
34:41 - 86 - Black Mask #01 - The Scarlet Fox
34:57 - 87 - Terror Tales #05 - The Dolls of Doom
35:15 - 88 - Mystery Fox #48
35:41 - 89 - Mystery Fox #49
36:05 - 90 - Mystery Fox #50
36:27 - 91 - Super Science #12 - We Guard the Black Planet!