11 1 4Actions Report Solution This achievement is missable and can only be done in the Prelude, right at the beginning. After unlocking the outhouse door with the key, return the pegleg to the Scurvydog Shack, it's as simple as that.Pegleg Achievement:Guide not helping? View 1 more guide for this achievement.Showing most recent comments. View all comments. Good to know, I unlocked the achievement without picking up the fake piece of eight. Might be a glitch ?Posted by ZodiaKk418 on 12 Nov 22 at 04:36 I had to pick up the fake piece of eight as well (Windows version). It didn't unlock when I put the key back without doing it first. Thanks for the guide and the comment about picking up the eight!Posted by KBop a doo on 12 Jan 23 at 12:49 Just to join in on the other comments the piece of eight had to be picked up for this achievement to work.Posted by AntaraelDulacre on 25 Jan 23 at 18:05 Leave a comment