Precision passes do not need to be enabled, they are enabled by default.
Default control settings may need to be enabled if you have changed them.
By pressing RB and Y you will get a line and a dot showing the path of the pass. You have a second or 2 to aim the intended direct of the pass before it goes off.
This achievement does not track on Xbox, so you just have to keep doing these type of aimed passes until it pops.