18 Jun 19
27 Jan 21

Nurture or Nature? achievement in Red Dead Redemption

Nurture or Nature?

Complete "Remember My Family".

Nurture or Nature?0
23 December 2020 - 5 guidesOffline Game ModeSingle PlayerMain Storyline

How to unlock the Nurture or Nature? achievement

  • StNowhereStNowhere65,430 65,430 GamerScore
    21 May 2010 22 May 2010
    91 4 11
    You get this achievement by completing a stranger mission after the final mission, "The Last Enemy that Shall Be Destroyed". Although it is a stranger mission, it is considered the final mission in the storyline, as the credits roll after its completion.

    You can find the stranger at the station in Blackwater. The mission itself is pretty self-explanatory, and, for spoilers sake, I won't tell you what to do. Just go to the purple circles on the map and talk to who you need to talk to. Easy 50g.

    Guide not helping? View 4 more guides for this achievement.

    Showing most recent comments. View all comments.
    KINGxOFxKUSH@G Smith007 once you talk to the politician in Blackwater he tells you that Edgar retired a year ago and is living with his wife down south, it is marked as a purple circle. find the purple circle that says "Remember My Family". Go there then youll find his wife and that he went hunting with his brother. Then find the circle again in a different location in Mexico. Youll find his brother cleaning his rifle, he will tell you that his brother is down the river hunting. Youll find Edgar, duel him, win the duel, pop.

    Also some other info on this achievement, when you kill him and the credits roll go to Edgar's body and loot it for ~$400.

    And if you take your sniper and look at his face his eyes are closed, but on his eyebrows are another set of eyeballs open wide, for me anyway. I thought it was a funny easter egg.
    Posted by KINGxOFxKUSH on 09 Jul 11 at 03:58
    Blazers Fan14The question mark isn't even showing up on the map for me...
    Posted by Blazers Fan14 on 13 Sep 12 at 17:28
    FishhInaBarrelIt's a black question mark on the map in black water it's called remember my family
    Posted by FishhInaBarrel on 24 Oct 13 at 01:20
  • Have you got any tips or tricks to unlock this achievement?
    Add a guide to share them with the community.

    Sign in and add a guide
  • AesiwattAesiwatt82,960 82,960 GamerScore
    24 May 2010 27 Sep 2010
    30 0 0
    This achievement is obtained after you have completed the final story mission.You begin it by going to a man in Blackwater, who can be identified one the mini map as a purple question mark, as all side missions are started. Follow the instructions, and when you get to the final standoff, put a shot in the person's groin, then the rest in his head (worked for me). After that person is dead, the achievement will unlock.
  • Buffalo OutlawBuffalo Outlaw2,276
    24 Jun 2010 23 Jun 2010
    23 6 0
    The man that you will need is to be found outside on the train station platform near Backwater. You will need to complete ''The Last Enemy that Shall Be Destroyed'' first.
There are 2 other guides for this achievement
Do you have a question about this achievement? Please post it in the Red Dead Redemption Forum

Related Achievements and Trophies