Posted on 08 January 16 at 18:57Daelus1 said:I think FO and Witcher were almost equal, but I give the slight nod to FO...very different games. Your take on what makes an RPG confuses me.....FO is far more an RPG than Witcher....in FO leveling matters, skill upgrades matter, customization matters, stats matter (as in SPECIAL stats)...in Witcher everything is interchangeable, no skill tree matters at all. I think you see fantasy setting and are confusing that with what makes an RPG. Witcher is a narrative driven story (a good one) in a fantasy setting with some RPG elements...it isn't far off Tomb Raider or AC.Personally, I have a completely different view of what "makes an RPG" - for me this means choice and influence over the storyline. The ability to define a personality for my character - by choosing some options over others. Witcher definitely has a lot of tough choices to make (most of them not black&white ). Comparing this to TR/AC misses the whole point of 'playing roles'.Whereas stats and leveling are natural for RPG's they do not "make" an RPG. Happy Wars has stats and leveling. I wouldn't call it an RPG though.