Editorials and Features

Forum for Editorials and other News Features

Ranking The Modern Telltale Games Library

  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 10:53Permalink
    Which tale is told the best?

    Please click here to read the story: Ranking The Modern Telltale Games Library
    Poll: Which modern Telltale game is your favorite?
  • 6.4% - Batman
  • 5.2% - Game of Thrones
  • 2.1% - Minecraft: Story Mode
  • 24.7% - Tales From The Borderlands
  • 27.6% - The Walking Dead
  • 3.2% - The Walking Dead Season 2
  • 0.7% - The Walking Dead: Michonne
  • 1.5% - The Walking Dead - A New Frontier
  • 28.6% - The Wolf Among Us

  • We had 3,295 responses to the poll.
    You must log in to vote on this poll
  • sorren101sorren101550,794
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 11:17Permalink
    I would have put Wolf among us in the top tier. TWD S1, Tales from the Borderlands, and TWAU are all incredible and I'd have a hard time choosing between them.
  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 11:19Permalink
    I absolutely hate TellTale games, but did enjoy Tales from the borderlands.
  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 11:28Permalink
    The Wolf Among Us for me, got it with GWG and didn't know anything about it before I started playing it. Story was amazing.
    Hero
  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 11:29Permalink
    A new frontier was definitely the best one in the series imo. Michonne was good as well though did not like the flashbacks.
  • ScubaSte3veScubaSte3ve557,865
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 11:43Permalink
    would have to agree..Tales from the Borderlands was hilarious
    GheeButt3rSnaps
  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 11:45Permalink
    Nice article, and I would agree with the rankings.
  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 11:46Permalink
    Clearly I need to play tales from the borderlands
    Happy Gaming
  • KingyOwlKingyOwl341,861
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 11:51Permalink
    sorren101 said:
    I would have put Wolf among us in the top tier. TWD S1, Tales from the Borderlands, and TWAU are all incredible and I'd have a hard time choosing between them.
    Agreed, these are the best three TT games I've played and worthy of "Tier 1" status IMO.
  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:08Permalink
    Season 2 ending of The Walking Dead had me in the fetal postition so that wins for me.
  • Mr AbductorMr Abductor428,882
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:12Permalink
    That bar fight in the end of episode one for TWAU was amazing
  • TiizmTiizm184,714
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:15Permalink
    Tales from the borderlands is the best game of all time 😋
  • Lost LegendsLost Legends1,247,518
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:16Permalink
    I'd swap where you have season 1 and 2 and say it's a pretty accurate list.
  • CODYWWE24CODYWWE2471,835
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:27Permalink
    Now while I like them all, I chose Batman because coming into the series, I didn't think that I would liked it but I did.
  • WyyvernWyyvern505,484
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:33Permalink
    TWD S1, I don't think they can top that. I didn't like Tales that much.
    Here be dragons.
  • LolliZombiLolliZombi265,824
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:42Permalink
    The Wolf Among Us is the only game in their library that actually has good story telling and differences with story choices. In fact given what they promise vs what they deliver it's the only good game, they've created. Now I like (even love) other games they have created but TWAU is the only one to live up to what they promise, and they have promised the same thing a lot
  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:44Permalink
    Wolf Among Us. I am so glad they will finally continue the franchise!
  • SplatadorSplatador316,554
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:45Permalink
    I didn't think anything could possibly top TWD, but Borderlands somehow did just so, IMO. From beginning to end, it was just perfect.
  • Posted on 23 July 17 at 12:56Permalink
    My personal top 3:

    1) Tales from the Borderlands
    2) The Wolf Among Us
    3) Jurassic Park

    I think Jurassic Park should be on this list. It is better than half of them.
  • GuruThaGreatGuruThaGreat951,910
    Posted on 23 July 17 at 13:09Permalink
    I know not all the episodes have been released, so therefore wasn't including here, but Guradians of the Galaxy is exceptional. I would already put it in my top 3, along with Tales from the Borderlands and The Wolf Among Us. I'd probably also have to put Batman in that top tier, but that might be for no other reason than I love Batman and the DCU in general. So I'm definitely biased lol.
Want to join in the discussion? Please log in or Register For Free to comment.