HawkeyeBarry20 said:Butters tK said:I Never Get Mad said:lol I see the writer really likes Tom brady
He is the goat.
This is a solid example of why I like Madden ratings and have a growing disappoinment with NBA 2K and their ratings. Madden goes on stats and play well NBA gives players with a bigger name and less talent better stats. If 2K were in charge Cam "Baby Back Bitch" Newton would be number one. Although to be fair I don't agree with the 4 and 5.
I really like the top 5. The tough thing about breaking in this 5 is if all retired today four would go to the hall. Ryan is the only one that would not but because of the season him and his team had he's a solid pick. Who would you take in place of 4 and 5? Carr had a heck of a year, maybe Rivers, hard to tell how he stacks ups against these guys since he always plays on a team that doesn't do so well, especially in the playoffs. Don't say Flacco or your argument is invalid, haha.
Oh trust me I would never say Flacco unless we are talking about overpaid bench warmers who's contract keep them in the starting spot.
I think Luck and Carr are the 4,5. Both Big Ben and Brees are definitely worty of respect but I don't feel they are top 5 right now. The bias Cowboys fan in me wants to knock Rodgers down a spot lol but that dude is an absolute monster. There is an argument for Wilson but I view him as a over hyped Alex Smith. The talent is there but he's a game manager not a game winner.