Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin Reviews

  • Danny Dubs 86Danny Dubs 862,038,910
    30 Aug 2015 30 Aug 2015
    13 7 4
    Originally posted (with pictures!) on my blog at http://takeaimandgame.blogspot.com/

    I only played Dark Souls for only a few hours when it was released before getting distracted, and I've only recently gotten back into the franchise. I reviewed Dark Souls, calling it one of the best games I've ever played, and I stand by that claim.

    After I'd gotten my fill of the first game, I decided to jump straight into the sequel. While initially off-putting, some of the changes to the Dark Souls formula grew on me in time, leading me to thoroughly enjoy the sequel, too. It's still a lesser game in most respects, but given the astronomically high bar set by its predecessor, that's not entirely surprising. Here's what the second Dark Souls game has to offer:

    (As a brief aside, a lot of my comments will compare this game to the original Dark Souls. That's partly because I played them in quick succession, but partly also because it's natural to criticize a sequel for its divergences. I know Dark Souls II has gotten some hate, but I think a lot of that hate is undeserved, so I'm inclined to address the bad reputation by drawing those comparisons explicitly.)

    The Good
    Dark Souls II (hereafter abbreviated "DS2") thrusts the player into a hostile, unknown world with very little explanation or setup. There's a brief introductory cutscene that is cryptic and virtually useless for setting the stage, so you're left to your own devices right from the start.

    You will find that the basic gameplay mechanics are the same as in Dark Souls. There is heavy emphasis on learning the game, adapting to its challenges, and executing maneuvers precisely, with hefty penalties for mistakes. You'll use bonfires as both small bastions of safety and respawn points. Dying causes you to drop all your accumulated souls (which function as the game's experience points and currency), but you can retrieve them if you can get back to the place you died. Most of the control scheme is even the same, too.

    From a broad perspective, it would seem that DS2 is more of what made the original so fantastic. But as you play, you start to notice small differences that leave a rotten aftertaste.

    I had gotten pretty proficient with combat in Dark Souls, after sinking around 80 hours into it, and from the start, DS2 felt wrong. As I continued, I realized that some of the timings were a bit off - there was a slightly longer delay after an attack before you could dodge, and you have to dodge at slightly different times to avoid damage from incoming attacks.

    Coming off the tail of Dark Souls, this situation was incredibly frustrating. The combat in the original was damn near perfect, so tinkering with it had to result in a less ideal setup.

    In retrospect, this subtle difference was actually a powerful feature because it forces Dark Souls veterans to relearn how to play. That trial and error and slow accumulation of skill was one of the reasons Dark Souls was so engrossing, and the small variations in DS2 come close to emulating it.

    I don't know if that was intended, but that's definitely the effect it had on me - I had to go through a similar (albeit quicker) process of trial and error to get comfortable with DS2.

    Another great modification to the Dark Souls formula is the inclusion of interesting ways to interact with bosses. In a handful of areas, you can do something outside of the boss fight that will change the dynamics of that fight. For example, one of the early bosses resides in a dark chamber. If you access a couple side rooms and ignite some flammable oil, you can light the arena and make the fight considerably easier. This feature rewards thorough exploration of the game's areas, which I think is fantastic.

    The Bad
    There are, of course, some other changes that I don't see quite so favorably: from the very beginning, you can warp from any bonfire to any other bonfire, making a return trip to, say, a blacksmith a much less dangerous affair than in Dark Souls. You also have to return to the main town in order to level up. Combined, these features are effectively the same as being able to level up at any bonfire, but in practice, it can get annoying as you have to pass through additional loading screens in DS2.

    In fact, there are lots of loading screens across the game, which gets to feel tedious pretty quickly. The Xbox One version in particular also has terrible servers for online play. It takes a couple minutes to connect to the servers upon booting up the game, and even then, the connection failed a few of the times that I tried.

    Then there's the baffling decision to stop spawning enemies eventually. After defeating the same mob a dozen or so times, they will not appear again until New Game+. As such, the game is a hell of a lot more forgiving than Dark Souls, because you can grind through areas by slowly exhausting all the enemy spawns.

    On the bright side, there's also a way to increase the difficulty of an area without completing the game and starting New Game+. It's a cool mechanic that will reset any depleted spawns and allow you to farm souls or items, if that's your thing, but I don't think it excuses the decreased difficulty overall.

    And I do think that DS2 is quite a bit easier than the original. Some of that is certainly because I didn't have to start from scratch in terms of how to play the game, and I knew exactly what I was getting myself into. Still, most bosses were disappointingly simple to figure out, and very few areas required more than a couple attempts to pass.

    Another big flaw is the overall structure of the game. Dark Souls was beautiful in that it felt like a sprawling world to explore, with all of the areas connected to each other in complex ways. DS2 feels much more like a series of levels - you run through a few areas and defeat the corresponding bosses, then you head back to the hub and pick a new branch. I'm not quite sure how the sizes of the worlds compare, but as a result of this more linear nature, DS2 feels a lot smaller.

    To be fair, I had a ton of fun playing DS2 despite these complaints. Yeah, the game is far from perfect, but it's still an excellent Dark Souls-style adventure.

    The Neutral
    Dark Souls had another major strength: the story. Unfortunately, DS2's world building isn't nearly as strong as its predecessor's. To be honest, I can't quite tell if the underlying mythology in DS2 is just weaker than in Dark Souls or if the storytelling is a lot subtler. I'm leaning towards the former, but either way, I picked up a lot less along the way.

    Fortunately, a weak story doesn't detract from the experience, it just means that there one layer of depth is missing.

    The one place where DS2 is a clear step up is in aesthetics. Visually, the game is stunning, with some incredible vistas and beautiful reveals along the way. There's nothing quite as dramatic as some of the best scenes in Dark Souls, but it looks damn good the whole way through.

    The audio quality, on the other hand, is just decent. The music is mostly forgettable (with one notable exception), though it generally fits the tone of the action pretty well. The voice acting is less awkward than in Dark Souls, but that's surprisingly disappointing, as it means that the characters you encounter are significantly less unsettling than the NPCs in Dark Souls. It's objectively better but much less immersive, as weird as that is.

    As a final tally of entertainment value, it's worth noting that my in-game time was around 30 hours when I defeated the final boss. I suspect that it would have taken longer if I hadn't played Dark Souls recently, but I feel like 30 hours is still a good amount of content, even excluding New Game+ shenanigans (which actually adds a ton of replay value, as New Game+ adds new enemy spawns and makes the game quite a bit harder).

    The DLC
    Everything I've written up to this point applies to the base game, so it should be true for any version of DS2. The Scholar of the First Sin edition is bundled with what were originally the DLC packages for the game. Those sections are of an entirely different caliber, so they're worth discussing on their own.

    The DLC areas are hard. They're really, really hard. Enemies hit a lot harder, bosses are absolute monsters, and the areas are much less linear, with more to explore and more chances to get lost. In short, they're much closer to what fans of the first game likely expect.

    And that's fantastic.

    It's a shame that you can't get this level of challenge in the base game, but I'm glad that it's in there somewhere. These sections are welcome end-game content because they can easily add 20+ hours to your DS2 experience.

    The Achievements
    The achievements in Dark Souls weren't exactly easy, but this one's worse. Most achievements will come naturally by exploring and completing the game, but you'll have to fight through some of the most difficult bosses in the DLC areas to nab everything.

    The real achievement tedium comes in two of the "Mastery" achievements - you need to get all the game's Miracles and Sorceries for 100% completion (like in Dark Souls). Doing so is a huge pain in the ass because you basically have to participate in multiplayer to get them.

    Multiplayer in and of itself isn't such a big deal; the problem lies in DS2's matchmaking system and the fact that the online community for this version of the game is basically dead.

    The matchmaking problem is that you can only interact with other players near your soul memory, which is the total number of souls you've accumulated. It's nice from a raw gameplay perspective, as you won't get ganked by somebody much more powerful than you, but it severely limits the number of possible multiplayer partners. This means boosting could be tricky.

    And the overall lack of people playing the game online means that you'll have a lot of trouble getting this done naturally without a boosting partner.

    Fortunately, there is some good news: there are offline work arounds for obtaining the miracle and sorcery that would ordinarily require online play. These work arounds are absolutely mind-numbing, though, as they require tons of grinding for items with exceptionally low drop rates. I've logged 100 hours on my save file and still haven't gotten the last Miracle (and I'm pretty far from it).

    While there are two incredibly tedious achievements, the rest don't push you far beyond normal gameplay, which is tons of fun, as I've described. So it's mostly not too bad.

    And that's really it. If you enjoyed Dark Souls, you'll probably enjoy this game, as long as you give it a shot. Loading screens may get a bit tedious, and you probably won't find yourself intrigued by the story, but it's still a fun action RPG.

    If you haven't played a Souls game, this isn't the one to start with. It's good for a few dozen hours of entertainment, but Dark Souls is still the better game.

    My Rating: 8/10 - great.

    UPDATE: I've played the original version of DS2 now, and I think it's worth noting that there are some significant changes in the Scholar of the First Sin edition. Those changes are mostly enemy spawns, and many areas have completely different enemy compositions in the two versions. As a result, it may actually be worth playing this version even if you've already played the original release, because a lot of areas feel different.

    (For more info on my rating system, including overall stats, see http://takeaimandgame.blogspot.com/p/reviews.html)
    Showing most recent comments. View all comments.
    AwooGood review. I'm sure you'll attract some negative votes because a lot of people don't like to see anyone saying anything good about this game, but I think you gave it a fair assessment. As someone hugely into the lore and story of these games, I prefer this one due to how it builds upon the first game, which I feel was mostly there to establish the setting. This one goes a lot deeper with exploring the concepts of light and dark, the cycles related to them, and the DLCs delve into the possibility of breaking the cycle as well. The one thing the game lacks compared to the first game is memorable characters, but overall I think that's not something it needed, as it's more about the world than the characters inhabiting it.

    But I'm done rambling, good job :) +1
    Posted by Awoo On 31 Aug 15 at 11:20
    Angels Kill TooDS2 is much better in my opinion.
    The environments are amazing and memorable and the music is very moving. Every area looks different and

    with DS1 it's idk kinda boring and everything looks the same, it's just not all there for me.
    Posted by Angels Kill Too On 07 Sep 15 at 12:43
    NINja277I agree w razor i liked the review, havent played it yet but feel like i know what to expect
    Posted by NINja277 On 07 Sep 15 at 15:25
  • Madknight 64Madknight 64467,686
    19 Mar 2019
    2 4 4
    Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin is an expansive and incredibly punishing game at times. There are mechanics in this one that are different than any of the other Souls Series (such as a health pool that shrinks with each death until you use humanity) and can take a little while to adjust to. However it is one of the most open worlds in the Dark Souls series, allowing you to go anywhere on the map and not pick a specific pathway. A fun experience, but approach it as you would a new experience or you may have a bad time

    Scholar of the First Sin also includes the three DLC for Dark Souls 2, though to access them, you will need to find certain items within the game. These DLC can be equally fun and punishing (it feels like some of the areas are meant to be played with other people). The three DLC are all fun and add more to the Dark Souls universe through visiting more about the abyss.

    The story within this game is told through the few friendly NPCs that you meet along your journey and the many items that you collect throughout the game. You are given an opening cutscene that explains why you are in Drangleic, and then you must figure out the story for yourself. The amount you learn is based off the number of interactions and items you find through out your journey and all of the environments you travel through on the way.

    The game won't hold your hand and explain why things are happening, or why the world is in it's current state. This is a pleasant departure from standard storytelling where everything is described in great detail to you.

    Game Play
    The gameplay in Scholar of the First Sin can be very punishing if you are not careful. The game requires trial and error as you fight your way through bosses and enemies, learning their attacks and movements. The leveling system can be quite confusing (though all the info is there, it can just take a long time to learn) so it can help to use a guide if you are feeling under powered or overwhelmed.

    The biggest advantage to Dark Souls 2 is that you are not on a scripted path. You can explore the world in any direction you want, and you aren't stopped (except by the enemies you meet along the way). So there are no locked doors or gates that are stopping you from going where you want to on the map.

    If you have played other games in the Souls Series, you may find some new gameplay changes difficult (such as the decreasing health bar, attacks going where the character is aimed by your controller, slower heals) but with a little practice and time, these don't end up being a big deal as you make your way further through the game.

    The visuals in this game are fantastic, and I would find myself at times stopping to look around (sometimes followed by my immediate death), but the views were worth looking at. The environments you travel through all feel unique and different, and there are many areas to explore through. The weapons and armor sets are also particularly good in this game.

    Last Thoughts
    I recommend this game to anyone one who is a fan of the Dark Souls Series, or any players that are just starting out. As with any of the games, they can be punishing at first, but the big thing is not to give up and keep trying out new things. Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin has some additional bosses compared to that of the original Dark Souls, and there are other enemies put throughout the game. If you haven't tried out this version I highly recommend it.