- Believing in ghost stories
Unlock all the cursed Black Pearl crew characters (Single Player Only)
Locked - 1 guide
- Do you fear death?
Unlock all the Flying Dutchman crew characters (Single Player Only)
Locked - 1 guide
- The pirate all pirates fear
Unlock all the Queen Anne's Revenge crew characters (Single Player Only)
Locked - 2 guides
- You may throw my hat
Collect all the red hats (Single Player Only)
Locked - 1 guide
- A weather eye on the horizon
Use a spyglass
Locked - 2 guides
- The Green Flash
Watch a sunset
Locked - 1 guide
- Hello, poppet!
Unlock all Elizabeth characters (Single Player Only)
Locked - 2 guides
- The Brethren Court
Unlock all the Pirate Lord characters (Single Player Only)
Locked - 1 guide
- The best pirate I've ever seen
Complete Port Royal in Story without dying
Locked - 2 guides
- The worst pirate I've ever seen
Complete Port Royal in Story with zero studs
Locked - 7 guides
- More what you'd call guidelines
Complete the Brethren Court
Locked - 1 guide
- A pirate's life for me
Test any custom character
Locked - 2 guides
- You filthy, slimy, mangy cur!
Complete all the Guard Dog levels
Locked - 2 guides
- Try wearing a corset
Do 5 lady backflips in a row
Locked - 3 guides
- What do you want most?
In any level use only the compass to find all it's secrets in one go, alone.
Locked - 4 guides
- Hoist the colours!
Sail all the minikits in the hub
Locked - 3 guides
- Parley!
Unlock all characters (Single Player Only)
Locked - 1 guide
- And really bad eggs
Play as all the Extra Toggle characters
Locked - 2 guides
- Savvy?
Unlock all the Jack Sparrow characters (Single Player Only)
Locked - 2 guides
- Wind in your sails!
Hit a flying parrot on Smuggler's Den
Locked - 2 guides
- Pieces of Eight
Reach 888,888,888 studs
Locked - 3 guides
- Did everybody see that?
High dive into the Maelstrom
Locked - 3 guides
- There's the Jack I know
Get True Pirate in all levels (Single Player Only)
Locked - 1 guide
- Sea turtles, mate
Ride on all types of animal in the game
Locked - 2 guides
- Gents, take a walk
Walk on the sea bed with all possible characters
Locked - 1 guide
- I am a bad man
Play a level with all Extras turned on (Single Player Only)
Locked - 4 guides
- Five lashes be owed
As Jimmy Legs, whip Will Turner 5 times
Locked - 3 guides
- Fire!
Fire 100 cannonballs
Locked - 6 guides
- You're off the edge of the map
Highlight the secret 6th point on all 4 level select maps (Single Player Only)
Locked - 2 guides
- Hello, beastie
Get eaten by the Kraken 10 times
Locked - 2 guides