Not since they cancelled Where in the world is Carmen Sandiego? has this geography nerd been so let down by geography trivia. Its not that I was expecting National Geographic Challenge! to blow me away with innovative gameplay or anything of the sort, it is just that a few adjustments would've made a world of difference.
For starters, no Xbox Live multiplayer, I know I'm writing this review a year post-launch, but c'mon, no online was as unacceptable in 2011 as it is now. Then there's little things like not narrating the questions, which wouldn't be so bad except there's a large graphic in between the questions and answers, which wouldn't be so bad except a lot of the points you receive are based on how fast you answer!
And why the hell is this game so damn British?! Nat Geo isn't a UK company, the developer is, and I don't care that they didn't localise (see what I did there?) to American English, what bothered me was that the questions are heavily tilted towards UK, Canada, and the Commonwealth trivia.
For what its worth, NGC is a really easy source of achievements, I rented it and knocked out most of them in one night. There are some multiplayer achievements, but luckily you can play multiplayer with a single controller. And it you're not much into Geography, not only is the easy mode extremely easy, but only a handful of achievments are score-based.
Unfortunately I didn't encounter some glitchiness unlocking achievements, there was one that I just flat out couldn't unlock despite doing what was needed several times, and some that I had earned didn't unlock right away but I did end up getting them while player other modes.
Bottom line: I like it when crappy games give you easy gamerscore, its the least they can do for sucking, and Nat Geo Challenge should get you an easy 800 or so gamerscore, but this game will disappoint you if you are a geography trivia fan.
2.0