- Learn to Swim
Free Scooter from his cage.
- Thought I Knew
Meet Theresa on the playground.
- Cry Beloved
Find the children's address for Theresa.
In a single playthrough, visit all the chapels.
- Before I Fall Into Despair
In a single playthrough, read all the messages written in sticks.
- Locked Around Your Spine
Find the secluded "pits" area.
- Looking for an Alienist
Find the medical facility in the woods.
- Room for One More
Find the empty grave.
- Dedication to the Cause
In a single game, stand on all the stages, cross all the bridges, and survive for an hour.
- Ending is the Beginning
Get to the end of one story.
- I've Always Been Around You
Get to the end of ten stories.
- Walk a Mile
Finished a game with all the different preacher personalities.
- Respect for All
Finish a game without anyone dying (during or after).
- The Unknown Unknown
Finish a game without being spotted at all.
- Written on the Wind
Finish a game in fifteen minutes or less.
- Live Hard
Finish a game on "Spy" or greater difficulty.
- One Shot, One Life
Finish a game on "Mole" difficulty.
- Never Liked Them
Finish a game without ever having a gun in your inventory.
- I Have Yet Begun
Started ten stories.
- Three Sides
Get Isaac & Rebecca's location marked on your map.
- On Brand
Find all five pins in one playthrough.
- Never Realized
Find ten documents in one playthrough.
- Maybe They Will Remember Us
Find thirty documents in one playthrough.
- Joining the Fold
In a single game, wear all the disguises.
- I'm Losing It
In a single game, fire all the guns.
- Just Some Air
Do three of any takedown.
- Feel No Pain
Do twenty of any takedown.
Distract three guards with rocks.
Distract thirty guards with rocks.
- I'm Just Looking for My Family
Stick someone up and search them.
- Soon I'll Let You Go
Stick up and search ten people.
- Until You Sacrifice it All
Get captured and hear from Isaac.
- Over and Over
Get captured ten times.
- Warm Embrace of Sleep
Hide someone in a trunk/closet/shed.
- Happy Place
Hide twenty people in trunks.
- Create a Villain
Get the alarm set off twenty times.
- Got a Letter from the Government
In a single game, destroy ten alarm boxes.
- Did You Forget Your Name?
In a single game, free five people from cages.