The Council Reviews

  • Slam Shot SamSlam Shot Sam921,149
    13 Mar 2018 18 May 2018
    15 1 4
    Click here for my verdict on Episode 2: Hide and Seek

    The Council - Episode 1: The Mad Ones | Xbox One | Review

    The Council isn’t your typical narrative adventure game, serving up a side of role-playing mechanics to complement the impactful decision making and branching story paths you’ve come to expect. You play Louis de Richet, a Parisian aristocrat and leading member of The Golden Order, a powerful secret society headed by his ageing mother. When she mysteriously disappears on a private island owned by the elusive Lord Mortimer, you board a vessel and set sail in search of her.

    Political intrigue soon abounds as Louis arrives to find leading world figures of the time, like Napoléon Bonaparte and George Washington, hosted in Mortimer’s affluent abode. Whilst outwardly putting their best faces forward, each attendee conceals a dubious personal agenda, leading a character and conspiracy-driven period drama steeped in late 18th century culture and religion.

    If that sounds a little indigestible, its mischievously quizzical soundtrack and a sense of humour prevent The Council from becoming too heavy by imbuing it with the unmistakable feel of a classic murder mystery caper. Importantly, that doesn’t undermine dark elements of the occult or Louis’ hallucinatory visions, seemingly stemming from chronic migraines, which incorporate further twists and turns by calling his perception of reality into question.

    Those elements serve to make your two-to-three hour stay a compelling one, but, unfortunately, that can be in spite of questionable voice acting and animation. Coupled with a script that lacks subtlety, when a character opens their mouth the game’s budget production value can cry out on occasion. That said, The Council is priced to match and the end result is more likely to make you crack a smile than let slip a groan, so it’s pretty easily forgiven.

    When it comes to presentation, the game’s setting fares much better on the whole. We’d describe the aesthetic as stylistically gruff - similar to Bethesda’s Dishonored - contradicting its inherent lavishness, presumably to reflect the ill deeds on which the surroundings were built. Priceless real-world paintings and artefacts are boastfully displayed on every available surface, aiding storytelling and also rewarding exploration given what little freedom you’re afforded.

    In taking the time to snoop you’ll gather collectibles, consumables and clues that’ll each help in solving simple environmental puzzles and conquering verbal confrontations. This is where the RPG elements come into play, with three skill trees offering up a range of unconventional abilities, either purchased through levelling or awarded for meeting certain criteria, that encompass an intellectual arsenal and serve to improve your powers of speech, perception and deduction.

    The Council isn’t your typical narrative adventure game...
    New interactions open up across the game as you acquire their corresponding skills, but you’ll have to pick and choose which instances to take advantage of, as performing actions draws from a limiting pool of Effort Points. What’s more, whether you might be forcing entry into a room, translating a document, or noticing small behavioural traits, there’s always a risk your efforts are misplaced and you won’t actually discern any useful information. When you pick your moment and do uncover a relevant morsel, character-specific vulnerabilities and immunities are compiled for reference and help you to politic with the best of them moving forward.

    Ingeniously, real-world historical knowledge can also be used to your advantage, for example, knowing Napoléon’s plans for the future of France makes it easier to curry favour by telling him exactly what he wants to hear. For the most part that’s off the cards though, so being afforded a few blunders during tense linguistic jousts helps to avoid blowing an encounter and negatively impacting your story - which it always will, in the absence of game over states. Before it comes to that, tactically popping one of four consumables, which offer a range of helpful buffs, can drag you back from the brink of disaster.

    Once you’ve gotten to grips with the ins and outs of the non-violent confrontations, they prove a fascinating advancement over the comparatively humble dialogue systems seen elsewhere. At this stage, The Council also seems set to dispel the infamous illusion of choice by actually bringing more significant differences between two given paths to the fore. You’ll visit contrasting locations and interact with different characters dependant on what you opt for, with each of these separate scenes then featuring more granular deviations within themselves. Ultimately, this leads to one of two very different cliffhanger endings, which certainly seems promising, though only time will tell how divergently the story continues to unfold across the series’ four remaining episodes.

    At the end of a chapter you’re informed of the events that you missed, putting the web of opportunities into perspective, and coupled with achievements for making opposing choices this provides compelling reason to start all over again.

    At this stage, The Council seems set to dispel the infamous illusion of choice by actually bringing more significant differences between two given paths to the fore.
    The first of The Mad Ones’ endings we encountered left us more intrigued than the second, but either way we’re eager to see where The Council takes us next. Until then, this rough-around-the-edges introduction to the series illustrates the strengths of its unique approach, placing it head-and-shoulders above anything from genre leader Telltale Games in terms of gameplay. While it utilises similar techniques to perpetually trap you between a rock and a hard place, keeping you actively engaged with its story, when it comes to scripting and performances, the experience just isn’t comparable.


    + Shakes up the narrative adventure formula
    + RPG systems make for the most engaging episodic adventure gameplay yet
    + Strong story & characters, in spite of some issues
    + Stylistic presentation is understated but effective
    + Very replayable


    - Dodgy voice acting & animations
    - Script lacks subtlety
    - Occasionally choppy frame rate



    The base list includes achievements for all five of the season's episodes, with a majority being assigned to this pilot. Whilst you won't simply be gifted a completion for finishing a single playthrough, as there are miscellaneous and divergent path achievements, a short second playthrough should set you straight. There's nothing challenging about it, just be aware that Veteran cannot be unlocked at this stage, as there's no way you're reaching level 15 in one episode.


    Originally written for Pass the Controller, a digital copy of the game was provided for the purpose of this review.

    Feel free to check out my other Xbox One (X) reviews, as well as my PlayStation 4 (Pro) and PlayStation VR reviews on TrueTrophies, and PC reviews on TrueSteamAchievements.

    Thanks for reading!
    Showing most recent comments. View all comments.
    Slam Shot SamThanks! Hope you enjoy it!
    Posted by Slam Shot Sam on 13 Mar 18 at 18:01
    FullMoonBeaverI enjoyed my first run through, and I’m already eagerly awaiting the next episode. Good review.
    Posted by FullMoonBeaver on 14 Mar 18 at 13:00
    SKORPIONICEnjoyed your review & for the first 10 minutes or so, this game was fantastic. After that I kept experiencing freezing, glitched load screens and was unable to even reload the save. I deleted and restarted my game, here's hoping that was just a hiccup.
    Posted by SKORPIONIC on 05 May 18 at 11:21
  • TheCharityGamerTheCharityGamer1,024,754
    18 May 2018 18 May 2018
    4 0 0
    Publisher: Focus Home Interactive
     Developer: Big Bad Wolf
     Players: 1
     Genre:  Adventure, Point and Click
     Launch Date: March 13, 2018
     Price: $6.99 for episode 1 $29.99 for the complete season
    The Council is not your average point and click game like the one from Tell Tall or Artifex Mundi that we as gamers have become accustomed to on Xbox One.  The Council takes the point and click adventure and adds its own RPG elements, dialog encounters, and levels of mystery that keeps you wanting more.  There are many different paths and although they don’t seem to make much difference but the game rewards you for interactions with different characters.   The game has it’s up and down and it isn’t perfect, but no game is, but it still remains a refreshing take on the narrative adventure formula.
     Story and Gameplay 9/10

    This game story is memorizing.  I was amazed how much I wanted to know what happens next even after the first episode concluded I just wanted more.  Basically you’re mother goes missing without a trace at a mansion on a private island.  You play as Louis de Richet and your task is to find out what happened to her and where she has gone.  Sarah de Richet aka the mother, is the leader of a top secret organization called the golden order which Louis is also a member of this secret order and finds out along the way that he is not the only one at this party that is.  The likes of George Washington, Napoleon Bonaparte, Elizabeth Adams, and others join the cast of as you try and figure out if they have anything to do with your mother’s disappearance as everyone seems to know her.

    The gameplay is exactly what you would expect.  You go around interacting with different people, collecting multiple different items, and solving disputes and using clues to complete your quests.  While you can useless coins (well useless in episode one at least) there are some very useful collectables you can grab.  There are books that help boost certain skills and consumables that have one of 4 effects which are:  The next skill you use has no energy, see whoever you are talking to immunity’s and exploits, an item to get rid of all negative effects, and a item that gives you back two energy.  Speaking of energy you can collect amber and 4 pieces of amber get you another energy box you can have.  Using skills require energy whether that be to convince someone you are right in a confrontation, find a new clue, or solve a minigame and runs out fairly quickly so it is best to be careful with how you use it.

    One of my favorite parts of this game was the confrontations with all the different characters.  You had to exploit their weaknesses and make sure to not use certain skills that are immune to get the result (and achievement you wanted) all included is a talent system.  Doing the requirements for a talent gives you a permanent bonus to one or more of your stats so you want to do as many as you can.  The characters are at their best during these dialogs and honestly it’s the only voice acting worth talking about but we will get to that.  This game is a very engaging experience and makes me want episode 2-5 tomorrow so I can play all of them back to back.
    External image
    [center]Decisions, decisions [/center]
    Graphics 6/10
    They aren’t bad but they aren’t amazing.  It’s a very stylistic approach and it my option it pays off.   I really felt like I was in a comic book and the drawings were coming alive around me.  Nothing is short of perfection unless you go towards a door to the outside that is unopenable.  If you head towards one of these many doors your character may get stuck in them and you will be forced to restart the game.  I did have a couple of frame rate drops but nothing to bad but enough to find itself this low on our scale.
    The one thing that stood out to me was that the cutscenes transitioned right into gameplay and vise versa.  The only loading screens in the whole game are when you leave an area for another one or between chapters and they last less than 5 seconds.  It’s a very well put together game and just needs some tweaks to push it up to a 7 or an 8.
    External image

    [center]Geroge Washington talking to you and the priest.[/center]
    Sound 3/10
    Ahh sound.  The one place this game completely fails.  It’s not so much the music or sound effects in the actually game it’s the voice acting and lack of emotion shown with most characters.  Now there are some exceptions to this like Elizabeth Adams who portraits the words and actions that are being shown through her with her voice.  When it comes to just about everyone else though no one shows any emotion whether that be surprise, fear, happiness, sadness, etc.  For example there is a scene in the game where Elizabeth Adams is acting hysterical saying someone is after her and they are going to kill her and the character you’re with just goes, “Meet me in your room later”  and then Louis says, “Elizabeth it is not a good time sorry.”  This women is obviously scared for her life and neither character batted an eye.   Also, small spoiler, SPOILER ALERT if you don’t go with Elizabeth she is found dead the next morning and your character shows absolutely no guilt in the slightest.  END SPOLIER ALERT.

    It’s this disconnect from human emotion that really made the game backpedal with what it was trying to do.  It almost had me not care what happens to these characters as they almost seemed like robots at some point or another.  I hope they fix this on upcoming episodes as it will make the game ten times better then what it is. 
    External image

    [center]Your words vs. a pistol, which one wins? [/center]
    Difficulty 3/10
    While it is not a hard game at all there are a couple of puzzles that if you don’t have the right skills or didn’t grab the right clue will put you through the ringer which makes you want to find those clues and do everything there is to do.  However at the end of the day the game remains very easy and I’m fairly certain a child could finish it.  There isn’t much here difficulty wise.
     Achievements 8/10
    What’s great about the achievements present in this episode is that all of them, despite the story based achievements, are linked to a talent you can unlock to make your character better at certain skills.  Now you can’t unlock all the achievements in the frist run but it’s simple enough to load up the other chapter and go do the achievement you missed without messing up your save, which is nice.  Now you don’t get to keep the talent points you get from replaying chapters so it is impossible to get them all, but that’s a different topic.  I loved the achievements in this first episode and I didn’t mind getting them it was interesting to see what would happen if I picked a different route.  You can complete this episode in just under 3 hours as long as you spend your points right but if you are like me you prolly won’t get the achievement to get a skill to level 3 but I’d imagine it will be easier as more episodes drop.
    External image
    [center]There are some very interesting views in this mansion[/center]
    The Council Episode 1: The Mad Ones is a delightful game that is surrounded in mystery.  Despites its awful and lackluster voice acting I did really enjoy this game and couldn’t wait to jump into future episodes to see what happens.   From the prologue all the way to the credits I was hooked and honestly I wanted to play the whole thing again with different skills to see if the outcome was any different despite their being no achievements to get.  I’d say the first episode is defiantly worth what they are asking and that any fan of narration or story will find a home here. 
    Final Score

    A copy of this game was provided by
  • Spring ShieldsSpring Shields262,591
    18 Jan 2020
    1 1 0
    This game popped up as part of an Xbox Live Gold sale for $9.99 CAD and since I enjoy story-driven, choice and consequence style games, I figured picking it up was a no-brainer.

    Along with it being a story-centric game, The Council also has some RPG elements as well, which allow you to add skill points to the main character as a Diplomat, Occultist and Detective. Each of those three main categories have sub categories that you can add skill points to as well. Increasing your skills in these sub categories allow the main character to access locked off dialogue options, study and obtain certain clues relating to solving puzzles etc.

    The first two episodes of the game start off rather well, there are some interesting dialogue and story options available as well as some interesting character interactions. Episode three is mostly filler and is honestly, rather forgettable. Episode four and five is where the game loses faith in itself, giving you the illusion of making some rather significant choices that could take the story in vastly different directions, only to have the game nullify those choices and railroad you down a much more linear path. The game has two endings and they're both kind of lame and cliched, ending the story rather abruptly.

    The games voice acting is absolutely terrible; the voices don't seem to fit their character models at all. Two of the main characters are of French origins, but are clearly voiced by North American actors. There are also lip sync issues that occur later in game, specifically during episodes four and five. That kind of breaks the immersion for me.

    There a number of times where the frame rate chugs concrete, dropping to like 21 FPS. This would happen as I'm running down a narrow corridor in a game that doesn't exactly live in a massive, open world.

    Overall, The Council starts off as an encouraging game, but definitely loses confidence in itself by the end. Couple that with the terrible voice acting, merely okay story and technical issues and I can really only recommend The Council at a deep discount and for curious fans of the story/narrative driven genre.