I used the Cincinnati Bengals for this achievement, but you can do it with any team that has a good rookie. The easiest would be Cincinnati (Burrow) or Washington (Young).
1. Go to franchise, active roster, pick Cincinnati, head coach, start regular season.
2. Max out all of Joe Burrow's attributes to make him a 99 OVR.
2.5. Also change his dev trait to X-Factor and when it is revealed you will unlock
3. Sim to Super Bowl, as this is when yearly awards get announced.
I got this first try using this method, but if you don't, just try again and it shouldn't take long.
Please feel free to message or comment with any questions. Happy hunting!