View Solution

The steps you mentioned for the achievement are correct but out of order.

1. Panic attack app
2. Don’t tell eddy about you being the one to kill your mom
3.Tell Michael you are different
4. Brake open chest

Fixed, thanks.

I mentioned this in the other solution, but I didn't have to physically break the chest to get credit for it. I simply inputted the code first thing and still got credit for "breaking it" since I didn't do the clue hunt.

I went ahead and added that you could enter the code or break it. Thanks for the suggestion

Can i do it in skip mode or reset the whole chapter???

Personally, I would suggest resetting the whole chapter since these achievements depend on decisions you make.

It worked for me, but I do think chapters 1 and 2 choices are important for this Achievement.

@AllysonDuck I was messaging with Maka last night and he seemed to have that issue. Just seems weird that you can get both following progress from 1 & 2, but some people have been having issues with choosing all bad choices and still getting strong bond.

Strong Bond - More than 50% good choices (whole game)
Weak Bond - More than 50% bad choices (whole game)
The Alyson vs Tyler ending may only be related to chapter 3 choices though, thats what im not sure about.

Can i do it in skip mode or reset the whole chapter???

@Rocker88 - answered you above, but I'd say go with resetting the whole chapter since the choices you make matter for this achievement.

Thanks

The way more flushed out, and meaningful ending tbh. The last quote, is very powerful

Seems like that’s the best way to go (though as part of the conversation above, depending on how you played the first two chapters, there’s a chance one of the bond achievement requirements aren’t met)

I did a full replay and chose every separating option. I did not lie to Eddie and did not get this ending. Lying to Eddie seems to be vital

Nope did not work

I got this achievement by replaying the whole game (unfortunately). I chose every option that benefited the twins being together. At the end, choosing "Mary Ann threatened Tyler" gives the ending of Alyson in the house to write the last chapter, along with the "Twins4Life" achievement. Choosing the other option has Tyler in the house at the end of the game instead.

Shame you can't have multiple saves…

I’m happy to play this game through again as I enjoyed it.

Am I right in that if I just choose all the bad choices for all 3 episodes I’ll get this achievement and the “life tears us apart” achievement?

FYI to break the chest in the loft, you have to go back down the hatch to the garage and pick up the crowbar which is on the floor where the fire was by the back door. Then go back up the ladder, and you should be able to break open the chest, just below the dials is the option. (you might have to play with the first puzzle a little bit first, which I did before going down the hatch.)
And like the other commenter says, closer to the end you should choose "Mary Ann threatened Tyler" (it's not as specific as "Mary-Ann was going to kill you"). Then you have to sit through a load of nonsense dialog with Tom, where you keep thinking "ugh, is this achievement going to pop soon?" But it's ok, just bang through the dialog and keep pressing skip. Then I finally got the achievement pop after sitting at Mary-Ann's desk and choosing "Write the last chapter" on the book on the desk.

In theory that should be correct.

I didn’t do it that way, I played through normal just choosing the decisions that felt best to me, and got the achievement. There are certain triggers needed for this one (seems lying to Eddie and choosing the left ending) and I’m guessing the same for life tears us apart.

Also, after "Telling Michael you are too different" (which is never actually worded exactly like that - so just pick the option that sounds similar), he says something about Alyson, and one of the options is something like "Yeah I never really thought about that." I picked this and it brought the twins' connection back together - so I would AVOID this option. It didn't effect me badly though because I still popped the achievement in the end. I just wanted to add this comment just in case it's a tight race for breaking twins' connection under the hood, you might not want this positive connection.

I’ve been trying to remember what that dialogue option was, but haven’t had any luck. If anyone remembers, I’ll add it to the solution.

Have replayed chapter 2 and 3 with only options that seperated the twins, didn't get the scene, still there was Tyler at the house (though I got the achievement for a weakened bond). I guess I will have to replay the WHOLE game now... omg... Takes some time for just one achievement.

Thanks for this. Was praying I wouldnt have to go back through Chapters 1 and 2 again to do this and thankfully I only had to follow this simple guide and got both the "new chapter" achievement and the "broken bond" too at the same time.

Weird. I did all of these negative options and I got the Tyler ending somehow...

Did you choose the left ending on the dock?

This Guide helped me out perfectly thank you!!

Thanks, this worked for me as well.
I'd already done a mostly good blind playthrough and gotten the 2 "positive" achievements: the twins having a strong bond and the ending with Tyler leaving the empty house.
Took me another pass where I started from the beginning of chapter 2 and did all the bad choices, but without having looked at this guide I passed the panic attack phone app (didn't even know you could fail it tbh) and told Eddie that Alison was the actual killer (because I wanted the weak bond and confessing to Eddie felt like it would do more to stir up trouble between them, even though you don't get the bond icon either way). Doing this got me the twins weak bond achievement but I still got the ending with Tyler.
So I started again from the beginning of the police station in chapter 3 and did exactly what you outlined here. I can't say for sure whether that would have worked if I'd been totally bonded throughout chapters 1 and 2 but I can certainly confirm that what you tell Eddie certainly seems to count for a lot.

So I did some experimenting. I replayed the entire game and only selected the choices that broke the twin's bond. Once I got to the conversation with Eddy in the third chapter I told him the truth, but otherwise followed this guide. I got the achievement for breaking the twin's bond, but got Tyler's epilogue.
I replayed from the "Paternity Test" section of Chapter 3. This time I did not tell Eddy the truth, but otherwise kept the rest of my choices the same. This triggered the epilogue with Alison.
Hopefully this info can help anyone trying to get this achievement or to at least make it quicker for them to pick it up.

I played through my first time and got this ending while doing the complete opposite, I beat the breathing game, told Eddy, bonded with Tyler, and beat the puzzles. The only thing I did was choose to stick with the story that their mum tried to kill them. For anyone willing to experiment this may be a final choice only trigger, as I reloaded from the choice outside of isolation mode and chose to believe Tom and got the other ending.

During my playthrough, I chose all the options to strengthen the twins’ bonds, passed the anxiety test, didn’t tell Eddie the truth, and originally accepted Tom’s version of events to get the ending with Tyler.

I restarted from “Veni, Vidi, Vecchi” (not in isolation mode) and sped through to making the decision again, this time choosing to keep the twins’ memory. This got my the Alyson ending.