I got it with Mason Crosby for the Packers. Got to where it was about 60+ yds on the field and had unlimited rewinds selected, missed the first one and nailed it on the 2nd try. I aimed the arrow all the way down so it would get the distance. You can also edit the stats for mason crosby maxing his kicking power and accuracy. Then goto My Madden>My Setting>Special Teams and max out the kicking power and accuracy slider.